USB stick not bootable using unetbootin on Mac

Bug #896686 reported by Steve L on 2011-11-26
60
This bug affects 13 people
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
UNetbootin
Undecided
Unassigned

Bug Description

Hi all. Just putting this in the system in case it happens to correlate with anything else you're looking at.

I downloaded the latest version (version doesn't show up when I run unetbootin, but it's the latest on the website) for my Mac, running OS X Snow Leopard 10.6.8. Used it with the following ISOs and installs:

FreeDos, EasyPeasy 1.6 ISO, and Acer Aspire One 3310 firmware update. Every time I created the USB image, it got "Missing operating system" when I attempted to boot from my USB stick on my Aspire One. I spent hours ... carefully formatting the stick FAT32, d/l'ing the latest unetbootin, etc. Really slaved at it ... tearing out my hair.

Finally I tried doing the download of unetbootin and the EasyPeasy ISO on the Aspire One itself, which at the time was running Kuki Linux, an old version from 2009. And what do you know, it worked.

Perhaps this will help the developers track down this intermittent but not-unheard-of bug.

The USB stick is a SanDisk 16G Cruzer.

Really hope you guys can track this down eventually ... I spent several hours hacking at this last night.

laurentd (laurentd) wrote :

Hello,

Same problem with Mac OS X 10.7.2

trying to "send" VMware_Esxi_5_iso on an USB Stick

     doesn't work (not bootable) using unetbootin on Mac OS X

     usable (bootable) using the same USB Key on a windows 7 VM (with vmware fusion, on the same Mac OS X machine)

Laurent

Ubuntu 11.04. Various OS and several USB sticks.
Always the same. I format etc. with either GParted or GNOME Disk Utility. Then I use Unetbootin. Everything appears to go OK but no matter what computer I try to boot the stick on I always get 'missing operating system'. I've checked the boot flag of course. I have also tried different formats Ext4, Fat 32 etc.
Very frustrating. Unetbootin has been like this for a long time.

Birger J. Nordølum (mindtooth) wrote :

I can confirm this with the latest 575 and Ubuntu 12.04. I've downloaded the desktop version, 64-bit. But states when put inside a regular machine that it's missing an operating system. Done via Mac OS X Lion.

Maybe you should provide an "app" that doesn't do what it should do? I've had this problem for a while.

Mikaela Suomalainen (mikaela) wrote :

This is Mac issue. Mac cannot boot from USB-device, or at least my Macbook doesn't allow that. I don't know about the new Macs, which come without CD-drive.

Mikaela Suomalainen (mikaela) wrote :

Please ignore my previous comment. I thought that you meant booting on Mac instead of booting on another computer, when device has been created on Mac.

This is very annoying. I'm not trying to boot my Mac, I'm trying to boot another machine with an image created using UNetBootIn on a Mac. It invalidates the use of the tool entirely if it doesn't make the disk bootable.

molecule-eye (niburu1) wrote :

I've got exactly the same issue, running OS X 10.8 (Mountain Lion) and trying to boot a Kubuntu 12.04 64-bit Live CD on a flash drive. I get the "Missing operating system" error on my brand new AMD A8-3870K desktop.

kronicd (kronicd) wrote :

Mountain Lion rather....

kronicd (kronicd) wrote :

http://perpetual-notion.blogspot.com/2011/08/unetbootin-on-mac-os-x.html has an explanation and fix.

The partition isn't marked as bootable and the MBR not written, could this be fixed?

RedLegoMan (red-lego-man) wrote :

Just my £0.02, this is still a problem even with the latest version. Is there any movement on getting this fixed for the OS X version?

Mephisto (artemjo) wrote :

Same problem here. OS X 10.8.3

wutzin (chris-siller) wrote :

Same problem here under OS X 10.7.5
Basically this bug means: unetbootin is COMPLETELY USELESS under OSX. So unless this bug is fixed, the team should pull the OSX download - why offer a program that cannot serve its intended purpose (creating a USB stick that is bootable on a PC)?

All the current osx variant does is to show a UI that pretends to create a bootable USB stick, but doesn't. Please stop offering a mac version as long as this bug is open - you will only frustrate users who will blame the linux distro they are trying to install (since unetbootin claims everything went well)

jackwhite21 (davidholland1989) wrote :

More of the same osX 10.8.4 .

Seems to work but will not boot on pc.

Changed in unetbootin:
status: New → Confirmed
status: Confirmed → New
status: New → Confirmed
noiseme (noiseme) wrote :

10.8.4. The same problem. USB isn't bootable with different os.

Quackers (quackers) wrote :

I found a workaround for this problem (at least it worked for me).
Could be worth a try
http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=2174630

Matt Ausmus (matt-j) wrote :

Since there is a work around, I don't think that you should pull the Mac version down.

This issue was originally reported in 2011 and I understand how open source projects work. Fixes happen when they happen. In the meantime, it should be in the FAQ or in a very obvious place that unetbootin does not perform it's full function as installed in Mac OS X. A link should be provided to the 3rd part posts or post the link in the FAQ itself.

Unetbootin is a great little tool but the Mac version just doesn't work and acts like it should and having to search the bug reports or the Google to figure this out inadvertently hurts the reputation of the project. It create much frustration and wasted time for all parties.

So, just update the FAQ and the when the fix comes everyone is happy and in the meantime you've provided notification and a work around.

Regards and thanks for a nice tool.

mariojuniorjp (mariojuniorjp) wrote :

e Bug has been reported in 2011, and we're in 2014 and developers not corrected. And look who is an open source project. I think if it was closed source, it would have been repaired for a long time!

To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  Edit
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers