Comment 6 for bug 581275

Revision history for this message
Chow Loong Jin (hyperair) wrote : Re: [Bug 581275] Re: cannot insert song from play queue into playlist

On 01/01/2013 04:58, Rüdiger Kupper wrote:
> I just discovered that the play queue cannot be shuffled. It stroke me
> as very odd -- why should I not be able to shuffle my play queue?? (Any
> answers? Of course not!). But, what the hell, if they won't let me
> shuffle my play queue, so I will just create a play list from my play
> queue, and this will be able to be shuffled. Well, good thought, but...
> there's simply no F*ING way top put all songs from my play queue into a
> play list.
>
> Is this a joke?
>
> If so, please stop joking, and start creating a useful player.
>
> If this is honestly what you think a player should behave -- get lost.
> It's ridiculous.
>
Banshee is useful as it is, with loads of features that other players do not
have. Please stop thinking that your (edge) use-case is the only use-case a
media player should support, and that it is useless if it doesn't support it.

In the first place, as I explained in Bug #1094953, you were obviously confused
about the role of a play queue in the media player when you clearly needed a
playlist, and that there *is* a shuffle button in the play queue that randomizes
the order of the play queue.

--
Kind regards,
Loong Jin