However it is worded, this bug does not meet the requirements for an open bug in THIS project. It is not related to software issues that can be corrected by the developers that are responsible for responding to bugs filed here.
This is an important discussion that I am eager to follow in the appropriate venues.
This is not one of those venues. This is a bug list utilized by developers working to make this project better through code.
Continuing the discussion here will not have any effect on the outcome of the overall debate. It's counterproductive to the developers on this project, and it's counterproductive to reaching any resolution on the matter.
Please, to add my voice to those who have already requested it, Take this discussion out of my bug queue. I have a job to do.