Comment 2 for bug 132840

Revision history for this message
Christian González (droetker) wrote :

Hm.
I think you have your boot partition because you have another linux, maybe as stable version, ant want to try out gutsy on a separate partition, but with the sme /boot partition.

On the first glance this seems to be a good idea, because you can select each of your operating systems within one menu.
But IHMO that is no good idea, because:

1. In debian/ubuntu there is an update-grub script which creates the automatic boot items. this script only chooses the kernels of it's own partition/system, all othere options you have to write per hand.
So in case you have your gutsy tribe 4 installed, and - as you wish - the installer adds your new gutsy kernel to the single /boot grub-menu, it has only the possibility to start it directly, like:

e.g.

title Ubuntu Gutsy Tribe 4
root (hd0,0)
kernel /boot/vmlinuz-blahblah root=/dev/sda3
initrd /boot/blahblah

And that as manual add, which means IT WILL NOT BE UPDATED IF YOU INSTALL A KERNEL UPDATE!

which is bad.

so you maybe see, "fixing" this would be an issue not only to this installer, but also to grub/debian scripts etc.

I think the much, much better way to do this is: keeping your boot partition, and install the gutsy GRUB into the partition, not the MBR.
Then you can manually add a "Testing" boot menu item which chainloads the partition bootloader.
Each system keeps separated.
You don't have to make another menu in gutsy, just don't prompt.

Hope that helps
Cheers,
Chris