Comment 22 for bug 284051

Revision history for this message
In , Dbeattie (dbeattie) wrote :

I noticed behavior like this on build 2002121215 of Mozilla 1.3a, on the
following image:

http://www.oqo.com/_images/H.jpg

It's a 4577 x 3597 pixel image, 1.2 megabytes in disk size. I found this out
from Internet Explorer 5.0 after Mozilla 1.3a froze up trying to load it.
Internet Explorer 5.0 loads the image quickly (assuming a fast Internet
connection) decompresses it completely into memory, taking about 20 MB of memory
to do so, and succeeds in displaying it. Some time after decompressing the
image, IE 5.0 seems to be able to release the memory even while keeping the
image in the browser Window, reallocating it when necessary to decompress on the
fly.

Mozilla, on the other hand, just froze up within a few seconds of clicking on
the link to load the image. I tried this several times... there were a few
instances where if I could get Mozilla to respond to the mouse click to close
the window, everything would come back and the program would keep operating as
normal. Mostly, I tended to give up and force Mozilla out of memory via "End
Task". I believe I was seeing the upper-left-hand corner of the image in the
Mozilla window appearing probably about a minute after beginning to load the
page;... I cannot be sure however, since I was unable to scroll the page to see
any more of the image. Perhaps as much as 30 extra megabytes... I can't say for
sure though whether it was more extra memory than IE 5.0 allocated at its peak
allocation though.

Operating System on my machine is Windows 2000.

I'm not sure whether this information correctly applies to this bug, or to bug
#9922
, so I'm cross-posting this information to both bug reports.

Thanks in advance for looking at it.

--David