Comment 4 for bug 50562

Revision history for this message
Eliah Kagan (degeneracypressure) wrote :

I think that saving the original description and providing an "original description" link like bugs have would be a better solution than restricting who can edit question descriptions, not just because of the reason that Diogo Matsubara raises, but for another reason as well: Sometimes people edit their own question descriptions in such a way as to render a pristine original useful. I have seen two subcases of this. On the one hand, people frequently add things to their question descriptions that would have been better provided by posting in the question, and that can make the original question confusing. On the other hand, occasionally people replace the *entire* content of their own question's description with an answer to a request for information, which makes the question extremely difficult or impossible to work on without getting back (or having the asker reconstruct) the original description. This happened recently in a question in which I requested information.