Comment 7 for bug 375547

I believe that behavior isn't the correct (KARL2) behavior. Tags are
"related" between users, not just "if you tagged the same resource
with another tag".

--Paul

On May 15, 2009, at 12:43 PM, Chris Rossi wrote:

> Ok, I've commited a fix for the problem which creates the error.
> However, there remains, in my opinion, still a higher level logical
> error that I'm not entirely sure what to do with.
>
> In the case above, with the fix in place, now, when you click on
> 'aryeh_neier' you're going to get a page with no results on it because
> the user, plonepaul, has not applied the 'aryeh_neier' tag to
> anything,
> and we are still in the plonepaul context using the
> profile_showtag_view.
>
> I see a couple of better behaviors for this:
>
> 1) Don't show related tags that weren't applied by profile user in
> this
> profile context, ie don't show tags not applied by plonepaul.
>
> 2) When clicking on a related tag, move out of the profile context
> into
> the global context. IE, instead of going to
> /profiles/plonepaul/showtag/aryeh_neier, go to /showtag/aryeh_neier at
> the site root. This way we'll see everything tagged with
> 'aryeh_neier',
> whether plonepaul did it or not. I think this is a bit more intuitive
> since I don't think the end user is going retain, mentally, an idea
> that
> he is still in a plonepaul context after having clicked away by a
> couple
> of clicks at this point. Especially, since there is no discernible UI
> element indicating that you are in the plonepaul context, other than
> the
> url in your address bar.
>
> 2 makes a little more sense to me. I've also looked at the
> related_tags
> code and I'm pretty sure that implementing 1 would be pretty hard and
> doing it in a very performant way would be next to impossible. Unless
> we can change the ITaggingEngine API.
>
> --
> Migrated tags under Related Tags gives UnboundLocalError on "related"
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/375547
> You received this bug notification because you are subscribed to
> KARL3.
>
> Status in Porting KARL to a new architecture: In Progress
>
> Bug description:
> Entering Tag on My Profile followed by enter - All Person's Name
> Tags Produces General KARL Error. Traceback code attached.
>
> To reproduce:
>
> 1) Go to http://kdiab.sixfeetup.com/profiles/plonepaul
>
> 2) Click on "africa" in "Paul's tags" portlet on right.
>
> 3) Click on "aryeh" in "Related Tags"
>
> This only happens for tags that are migrated. New tags don't have
> this problem.