Comment 2 for bug 1002023

I agree that the large Dmedia icon needs work. For reference, I designed the original icon as an indicator icon only. Although we currently use the same icon in the panel, this was just a stop gap. Your proposed icon could replace what's in the panel, but not the indicator.

Anyway, I think the gradient and shadows are definite improvements. However, I don't like how thick the grey boarders are in your version... feels too heavy to me, and is too big a departure from the indicator. I don't think we should try to design this icon to look passable from 16x16 to infinity. Instead, I think it should be designed to look great in the launcher at the default size.

If you rework this to keep the proportions of the indicator icon, or at least stay a lot closer too it, then I'll merge this.

Also, if you want things quickly reviewed and possibly accepted... I recommend not starting the conversation with, "current X sucks bigtime" :)

Cheers!