Comment 17 for bug 1902254

Revision history for this message
Mauricio Faria de Oliveira (mfo) wrote :

Verification done for focal-proposed.
No regressions in the consistent/flaky fail sets.

The flaky fail set had a long tail (tests that failed just a few times),
but it can be isolated to another btrfs commit, and it doesn't seem to
happen often. (e.g. not seen on focal-proposed, but seen on focal orig
kernel on master-next, and both have the commit.)
Thus not a general/permanent issue. More details in the next comment.

Proposed kernel:
---

$ uname -rv
4.15.0-125-generic #128-Ubuntu SMP Mon Nov 9 20:45:41 UTC 2020

$ VERSION='4.15.0-125-generic #128-Ubuntu'

Number of runs:

$ grep -h -e ^Fail -e ^PLATFORM xfstests.log.* | grep -A1 "$VERSION" | grep -c Failures:
14
$ RUNS=14

Consistent fail set:

$ grep -h -e ^Fail -e ^PLATFORM xfstests.log.* | grep -A1 "$VERSION" | grep ^Failures: | cut -d' ' -f2- | tr ' ' '\n' | sort | uniq -c | sort | grep -w $RUNS
     14 btrfs/186
     14 btrfs/193
     14 btrfs/200
     14 btrfs/202
     14 btrfs/204
     14 btrfs/205
     14 btrfs/214
     14 btrfs/219
     14 btrfs/220
     14 btrfs/221
     14 btrfs/222
     14 generic/260
     14 generic/286
     14 generic/301
     14 generic/371
     14 generic/405
     14 generic/407
     14 generic/465
     14 generic/480
     14 generic/488
     14 generic/502
     14 generic/513
     14 generic/526
     14 generic/527
     14 generic/546
     14 generic/562
     14 generic/565

Flaky fail set:

$ grep -h -e ^Fail -e ^PLATFORM xfstests.log.* | grep -A1 "$VERSION" | grep ^Failures: | cut -d' ' -f2- | tr ' ' '\n' | sort | uniq -c | sort | grep -w -v $RUNS
      1 btrfs/001
      1 btrfs/147
      1 btrfs/148
      1 btrfs/149
      1 btrfs/150
      1 btrfs/151
      1 btrfs/152
      1 btrfs/153
      1 btrfs/155
      1 btrfs/156
      1 btrfs/159
      1 btrfs/164
      1 btrfs/165
      1 btrfs/166
      1 btrfs/168
      1 btrfs/169
      1 btrfs/170
      1 btrfs/171
      1 btrfs/172
      1 btrfs/173
      1 btrfs/174
      1 btrfs/177
      1 btrfs/178
      1 btrfs/179
      1 btrfs/180
      1 btrfs/181
      1 btrfs/182
      1 btrfs/183
      1 btrfs/184
      1 btrfs/187
      1 btrfs/188
      1 btrfs/190
      1 btrfs/196
      1 btrfs/197
      1 btrfs/199
      1 btrfs/206
      1 btrfs/207
      1 btrfs/208
      1 btrfs/213
      1 btrfs/217
      1 generic/003
      1 generic/017
      1 generic/031
      1 generic/033
      1 generic/037
      1 generic/038
      1 generic/039
      1 generic/040
      1 generic/041
      1 generic/043
      1 generic/044
      1 generic/045
      1 generic/046
      1 generic/047
      1 generic/048
      1 generic/049
      1 generic/050
      1 generic/051
      1 generic/052
      1 generic/053
      1 generic/054
      1 generic/055
      1 generic/057
      1 generic/059
      1 generic/062
      1 generic/064
      1 generic/065
      1 generic/066
      1 generic/067
      1 generic/068
      1 generic/069
      1 generic/071
      1 generic/073
      1 generic/076
      1 generic/077
      1 generic/079
      1 generic/081
      1 generic/082
      1 generic/083
      1 generic/084
      1 generic/090
      1 generic/103
      1 generic/104
      1 generic/297
      1 generic/324
      1 generic/325
      1 generic/464
      1 generic/518
      2 btrfs/106
      2 btrfs/107
      2 btrfs/110
      2 btrfs/111
      2 btrfs/112
      2 btrfs/114
      2 btrfs/115
      2 btrfs/116
      2 btrfs/117
      2 btrfs/118
      2 btrfs/119
      2 btrfs/120
      2 btrfs/121
      2 btrfs/122
      2 btrfs/123
      2 btrfs/126
      2 btrfs/127
      2 btrfs/128
      2 btrfs/129
      2 btrfs/130
      2 btrfs/131
      2 btrfs/132
      2 btrfs/133
      2 btrfs/134
      2 btrfs/135
      2 btrfs/136
      2 btrfs/137
      2 btrfs/138
      2 btrfs/139
      2 btrfs/144
      2 btrfs/145
      2 btrfs/146
      2 btrfs/189
      2 btrfs/191
      2 generic/056
      2 generic/085
      2 generic/089
      2 generic/101
      2 generic/102
      2 generic/509
      2 generic/510
      2 generic/601
      2 generic/602
      2 generic/603
      2 generic/604
      2 generic/605
      2 generic/606
      2 generic/607
      2 generic/608
      2 generic/610
      2 generic/611
      2 shared/002
      2 shared/032
      3 btrfs/076
      3 btrfs/077
      3 btrfs/079
      3 btrfs/080
      3 btrfs/082
      3 btrfs/083
      3 btrfs/084
      3 btrfs/085
      3 btrfs/086
      3 btrfs/087
      3 btrfs/088
      3 btrfs/089
      3 btrfs/090
      3 btrfs/091
      3 btrfs/092
      3 btrfs/093
      3 btrfs/094
      3 btrfs/095
      3 btrfs/096
      3 btrfs/097
      3 btrfs/098
      3 btrfs/099
      3 btrfs/102
      3 btrfs/103
      3 btrfs/104
      3 btrfs/105
      3 btrfs/108
      3 btrfs/109
      3 btrfs/113
      3 btrfs/210
      3 btrfs/211
      3 btrfs/212
      3 btrfs/215
      3 btrfs/224
      3 btrfs/226
      3 generic/015
      3 generic/018
      3 generic/027
      3 generic/029
      3 generic/030
      3 generic/032
      3 generic/034
      3 generic/600
      4 btrfs/057
      4 btrfs/058
      4 btrfs/059
      4 btrfs/060
      4 btrfs/061
      4 btrfs/062
      4 btrfs/063
      4 btrfs/064
      4 btrfs/065
      4 btrfs/066
      4 btrfs/067
      4 btrfs/068
      4 btrfs/069
      4 btrfs/070
      4 btrfs/071
      4 btrfs/072
      4 btrfs/073
      4 btrfs/074
      4 btrfs/075
      4 btrfs/081
      4 btrfs/203
      4 btrfs/209
      4 generic/520
      4 generic/589
      4 generic/590
      4 generic/592
      4 generic/593
      4 generic/594
      4 generic/595
      4 generic/599
      5 btrfs/042
      5 btrfs/043
      5 btrfs/044
      5 btrfs/045
      5 btrfs/046
      5 btrfs/047
      5 btrfs/048
      5 btrfs/049
      5 btrfs/050
      5 btrfs/051
      5 btrfs/052
      5 btrfs/053
      5 btrfs/054
      5 generic/476
      5 generic/584
      5 generic/585
      5 generic/588
      6 btrfs/035
      6 btrfs/036
      6 btrfs/037
      6 btrfs/038
      6 btrfs/039
      6 btrfs/040
      6 btrfs/041
      6 btrfs/055
      6 btrfs/056
      6 generic/322
      6 generic/573
      6 generic/574
      6 generic/575
      6 generic/576
      6 generic/577
      6 generic/579
      6 generic/580
      6 generic/581
      6 generic/582
      6 generic/583
      7 btrfs/026
      7 btrfs/027
      7 btrfs/029
      7 btrfs/030
      7 btrfs/031
      7 btrfs/032
      7 btrfs/033
      7 btrfs/034
      7 generic/531
      7 generic/570
      7 generic/572
      8 btrfs/028
      8 btrfs/201
      8 generic/501
      8 generic/563
      8 generic/566
      8 generic/567
      8 generic/569
     11 btrfs/078
     11 generic/175 << increase, seen w/ test/patched kernel; from other btrfs patches. (comment #7)
     13 btrfs/010
     13 generic/074
     13 generic/133
     13 generic/142
     13 generic/143
     13 generic/475