Activity log for bug #188797

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2008-02-04 00:44:37 TimBaldwin bug added bug
2008-02-04 00:45:44 TimBaldwin bug added attachment 'update-manager.tgz' (update-manager.tgz)
2008-02-04 15:19:26 Michael Vogt update-manager: status New Incomplete
2008-03-16 20:46:09 Brian Murray update-manager: status Incomplete Invalid
2008-03-16 22:50:57 TimBaldwin bug added attachment 'dist-upgrade.tgz' (Extra diagnostics)
2008-03-17 21:47:30 Brian Murray update-manager: importance Undecided Medium
2008-03-17 21:47:30 Brian Murray update-manager: status Invalid Confirmed
2008-12-17 01:11:55 Dimitrios Symeonidis description Binary package hint: update-manager I initially tried upgrading from feisty to gutsy (running amd64) the easy way via the update notifier, which failed without any useful error messages. I then tried it again from the command line via aptitude hoping to get some more useful information, but it only got me: # do-release-upgrade Checking for a new ubuntu release Done Upgrade tool signature Done Upgrade tool Done downloading extracting '/tmp/tmpAwENSE/gutsy.tar.gz' authenticate '/tmp/tmpAwENSE/gutsy.tar.gz' against '/tmp/tmpAwENSE/gutsy.tar.gz.gpg' Reading cache Checking package manager Reading package lists: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty Release.gpg Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates Release.gpg Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty Release Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates Release Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty Release Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates Release Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/main Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/restricted Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/main Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/restricted Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/universe Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/multiverse Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/universe Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/multiverse Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/main Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/restricted Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/main Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/restricted Sources Done http://c.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-backports Release.gpg Done http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security Release.gpg Hit http://c.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-backports Release Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security Release Done http://c.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-backports Release Done http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security Release Hit http://c.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-backports/main/debian-installer Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/main Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/restricted Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/main Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/restricted Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/universe Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/multiverse Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/universe Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/multiverse Sources Done downloading Reading package lists: Done feisty-backports/main/debian-installer Packages: 93 Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Done http://c.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-backports/main/debian-installer release-upgrader-dpkg 1.14.5ubuntu11.2 Done http://c.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-backports/main/debian-installer release-upgrader-apt 0.6.46.4ubuntu10.3 Done downloading Reading cache Checking package manager Reading package lists: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty Release.gpg Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates Release.gpg Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty Release Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty Release Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates Release Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates Release Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/main Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/restricted Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/main Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/restricted Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/universe Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/multiverse Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/universe Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty/multiverse Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/main Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/restricted Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/main Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com feisty-updates/restricted Sources Done http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security Release.gpg Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security Release Done http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security Release Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/main Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/restricted Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/main Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/restricted Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/universe Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/multiverse Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/universe Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com feisty-security/multiverse Sources Done downloading Updating repository information Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy Release.gpg Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates Release.gpg Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy Release Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy Release Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates Release Done http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates Release Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/main Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/restricted Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/main Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/restricted Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/universe Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/multiverse Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/universe Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy/multiverse Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates/main Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates/restricted Packages Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates/main Sources Hit http://au.archive.ubuntu.com gutsy-updates/restricted Sources Done http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security Release.gpg Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security Release Done http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security Release Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/main Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/restricted Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/main Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/restricted Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/universe Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/multiverse Packages Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/universe Sources Hit http://security.ubuntu.com gutsy-security/multiverse Sources Done downloading Checking package manager Reading package lists: Donegutsy-security/multiverse Packages: 93 Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Asking for confirmation Support for some applications ended Canonical Ltd. no longer provides support for the following software packages. You can still get support from the community. If you have not enabled community maintained software (universe), these packages will be suggested for removal at the end of the upgrade. binfmt-support emacs21 emacs21-bin-common emacs21-common feisty-session-splashes festlex-cmu festlex-poslex festvox-kallpc16k gcj-4.1-base gij-4.1 gnome-cups-manager gxine libdb3 libevms-2.5 libgcj7-jar libgda2-3 libgda2-common libglib1.2 libgnomecupsui1.0-1c2a libgtk1.2 libgtk1.2-common liblzo1 libportaudio0 libslab0 libstlport5.1 libttf2 libxmlsec1 libxmlsec1-nss libxmlsec1-openssl openoffice.org-filter-mobiledev pmount rcs ttf-baekmuk vnc-common xmms xvncviewer Restoring original system state Aborting Reading package lists: Donefeisty-security/multiverse Packages: 93 Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done Reading state information: Done again, without really telling me much. Poking around in /usr/share/update-manager similarly didn't turn up anything of note (I can attach all the files if this will help). There was a reported bug with evms for upgrades in a related bug report, but uninstalling this had no effect. Any ideas what is going on? Tim As the title says: if a package is kept, the version upgrade process (both through the update-manager gui and from do-release-upgrade) fails without providing the user with any useful explanation... Instead, you should get something like: "Package xyz is kept back on your system, which makes a version upgrade impossible. Please unlock this package and start the upgrade process again."
2008-12-17 01:11:55 Dimitrios Symeonidis title upgrade from feisty to gutsy fails version upgrade fails without a warning if a package is kept
2008-12-17 01:12:38 Dimitrios Symeonidis update-manager: status Confirmed Triaged
2008-12-17 01:12:38 Dimitrios Symeonidis update-manager: statusexplanation This may have something to do with packages you have installed from feisty-backports. I am confirming this for you. I did notice this your logs - "2008-02-04 11:47:28,544 ERROR Dist-upgrade failed: 'E:Error, pkgProblemResolver::Resolve generated breaks, this may be caused by held packages.'"
2010-08-20 15:55:26 Dimitrios Symeonidis removed subscriber Dimitrios Symeonidis