Naming inconsistency within default applications
Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ubuntu-meta (Ubuntu) |
Invalid
|
Undecided
|
Unassigned |
Bug Description
Ubuntu has a thing for naming their applications inconsistently. Here's an example: When Hardy first shipped, Transmission was just named "Transmission" while Firefox was named "Firefox Web Browser" and Pidgin "Pidgin Internet Messenger." It didn't explain what it did and was confusing, although the Ubuntu team fixed it in 8.04.1.
Why is Totem just "Movie Player" when Rhythmbox is "Rhythmbox Music Player" instead of it too being just "Music Player"? There needs to be more consistency, which would prompt the change from "Movie Player" to "Totem Movie Player."
I have realized that all applications from GNOME have their names taken out. (For example, EOG is "Image Viewer" instead of "EOG Image Viewer." Same with Totem.) But with all other applications having their respectable names in the menus, I just think Totem should too. (And maybe EOG too.)
You're probably better of making a specification, rather than reporting a bug about this See https:/ /wiki.ubuntu. com/LaunchpadHo wTo#Specificati ons for advice on that. Bringing it up directly on the ubuntu-desktop mailing list, so that we can get a consistent policy on this may be a good idea.
There's been a debate on gnomes desktop-devel-list(http:// mail.gnome. org/archives/ desktop- devel-list/ 2008-July/ msg00165. html) about this recently, nothing was actually decided on though.
Fedora also had a proposal at https:/ /www.redhat. com/archives/ fedora- devel-list/ 2007-September/ msg01503. html which again hasn't been implemented as far as I know.