Comment 5 for bug 1040996

Revision history for this message
Dimitri John Ledkov (xnox) wrote : Re: Not offered "Install alongside" if other OS isn't Windows or Ubuntu

Dear original submitter - can you please reconfirm the disk partitioning scheme used? Was it LVM with separate /boot?

One thing to note is that from the logs the reporter's machine suggests that it is installed on top of LVM.
Currently LVM is ambiguous from auto-resize point of view.

From implementation point of view, the resize (aka alogside install) is available when:
* existing installation is single full disk (e.g. full disk linux/windows)
* where there is sufficient amount of free space available in that partition to perform a resize
* there is sufficient amount of space left to install ubuntu if resize is attempted
* the partitioner understands how to resize that file system

This is pre-requisites =)
Now the caveats

* the resizing may fail if the extends are allocated in a such a way that a resize without defragmentation is not possible, or not supported enough by existing tools.

This is ambiguous from LVM point of view, because:
* do you want to resize the VG & create a separate normal partition - OR - do you want to create ubuntu lvm volumes within that group?
* where should the boot loader go to?

Sorry for not checking the auto-collected logs more carefully when first looking into the bug. Thank you mpt for updating the Partitioning Options Matrix ;-) I was previously interpolating options while reading it.