Comment 36 for bug 1164016

Revision history for this message
Adam Dingle (adam-yorba) wrote :

Dr. Osman, thanks for your patch. A few comments:

1. Of course, this patch does not restore type-ahead find as originally requested in this bug ticket. Instead, it simply disables recursive searching, so that as you type only files in the current directory are returned. Still, this does significantly ease the pain of this upstream change. If Ubuntu can't summon the resources to restore type-ahead find in 13.10, I would recommend landing this patch since it's ultra-simple and does make things less painful. I'd further recommend modifying the patch so that non-recursive search is the default (as it stands, the user must set a GSettings key to disable recursive search, and few users will figure out how to do that). The GSettings key would then let users *enable* recursive search if they really want to. I suspect that few users will.

2. You really should be patching Nautilus 3.8.2, which is the current version of Nautilus in Ubuntu 13.10, where this is most likely to land. (I wouldn't mind seeing this backported to 13.04 either, though.)

3. In the patch, I believe you could simplify this code:

if (g_settings_get_boolean (nautilus_preferences, NAUTILUS_PREFERENCES_ENABLE_RECURSIVE_SEARCH)) {
  g_object_set (simple_provider, "recursive", TRUE, NULL);}
 else
 {
 g_object_set (simple_provider, "recursive", FALSE, NULL);
 }

to:

gboolean recursive = g_settings_get_boolean (nautilus_preferences, NAUTILUS_PREFERENCES_ENABLE_RECURSIVE_SEARCH));
g_object_set(simple_provider, "recursive", recursive, NULL);

Fewer lines are better. :)