Comment 20 for bug 872220

Revision history for this message
DooMMasteR (winrootkit) wrote :

passing 'bootdegraded=true' is no solution

so far I have found no way to boot my system.
As long as a disk which is part of an incomplete RAID is connected I will always end up in a BusyBox recovery shell, one way or another.

this is really annoying and can by far not be an intended feature…
it also does not matter if the RAID is included in mdadm.conf or if it is completely empty

I would understand this way of problem handling if the RAID contained essential data and was needed, but it will never be mounted during bootup and also is not contained in fstab, it is as if a broken device just prevents your system from bootup (in fact any USBthumbdrive with a Superblock describing it as part of a large RAID will do that)

I can obviously just disconnect my disks but that is not the case if the machine is unattended and had to reboot for one reason or another, when the RAID is not synced it will just fail to boot (there would not even be sshd running to offer remote access)

we had that situation before and I could then force assemble the RAID remotely but only because 10.04 would boot even with an degraded RAID attached