Comment 118 for bug 952080

Revision history for this message
In , alvarezp (alvarezp-linux-kernel-bugs) wrote :

(in reply to #80)

>> The fact that the working boards seem to have no +5V/+5VSB jumper could be a
>> hint that it's bug in the electric circuit.
>
> That's more or less what I've been saying ever since comment #45.

Not necessarily. If devices are still powered during S3, this simply means that OHCI is hardwired to 5VSB without a setting to bring it back to 5V, which just brings us back to "works as designed by Asus" and the recommended setting to all motherboards is to jump the OHCI to 5VSB.

I think that if OHCI is designed by the spec to wake up on USB disconnects, then everything is working fine. It's just an integration problem.