Comment 11 for bug 867811

Revision history for this message
Niclas Lockner (niclasl) wrote :

@Joseph
"I noticed you upgraded to Oneiric on 2011-09-28. Were you having this issue before you upgraded?"
I'm almost certain that I did a fresh install from a daily image instead of upgrading from Natty.
I can't tell when the bug started to occur since I usually never disconnect the NTFS disk.
If it is to any help, I could download and run a live CD of Natty and test?

"I believe you confirmed this only happens with NTFS?"
When I excluded ext4 and fat32 I used a USB stick to do some quick testing. I now did some new tests with the same USB stick and I found that regardless of the file system used (tested ext2/3/4, fat, ntfs), the system didn't freeze when the stick was safely removed. Of course I should have taken the time to test the stick with NTFS from the start. Sorry for the confusion.
I can therefore no longer say that it is NTFS only since I can only reproduce the freeze using my external hard drive (which I unfortunately cannot reformat and test with other file systems).

I've tested with the upstream kernels that you gave me and I could not boot any kernels at all from 3.0.5 up to 3.1rc9. I never came past the plymouth screen. After booting into onerics kernel again, I received the paging request error from Apport mentioned above by Nicolás.