Comment 44 for bug 584048

Revision history for this message
Serge Hallyn (serge-hallyn) wrote :

I'm looking over the history of this particular bug, and there at least
3 or 4 different bugs represented here. We should have been stricter
from the start about filing separate bugs.

@Billy Charlton

Can you tell us whether you are still having a problem? Yours appears
likely to be a bug in the bridge driver, so if you are, then I'd like
to have you test the pre-preposed kernel packages from
https://launchpad.net/~kernel-ppa/+archive/pre-proposed).

@Andrew

thanks for testing. I'd like to try a few things, but I need your bug
kept separate from the others. Can you please file a *new* bug (refuse
any suggestions at duplicates for now)? Please re-attach your
/etc/network/interfaces, output of 'iptabes -L' and 'netstat -nr',
'brctl show', 'ifconfig -a' (with a VM up), 'qemu --version', 'libvirtd
--version', 'uname -a', the contents of /etc/libvirt/qemu/network/*, and
the xml of a sample VM that fails? If any VM does not lose
connectivity, then include that too, but I don't think any is. (I
have specific questions I had started to write out, but will reserve them
for the new bug) I really am eager to look into this one, but need
the information segragated. Thanks!

@angriukas

Near as I can tell, the fix I've committed is actually for *your* bug
(which is still separate from Frank's, Billy's, Andrew's, and Santi's).
Ideally you would (a) open a new bug, specify that you lose connectivity
on guest shutdown, and comment on whether the proposed fix works for
you.

(Note to self - I suspect Jurgen's is the same as Frank's)

The status of THIS bug is to be set only based on feedback from Billy.
Setting to incomplete for now.