Comment 66 for bug 335761

Revision history for this message
In , Qik00 (qik00) wrote :

(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #62)
> (In reply to David Nemeskey from comment #60)
> > 1. Yes, what I described is the lack of the feature in the Gnome / Cinnamon
> > ecosystem as a whole. However, at least some applications (and key
> > applications like Terminal, Synaptic, etc.) do it, which makes it a much
> > more acceptable experience than in KDE (speaking from memory here, but the
> > issue is still open, so...)
> For sure. Similar,y, some KDE applications already support this
> individually, such as Discover and Elisa.
>
> > 2. The fact that some applications do it means it is possible, and was
> > possible even with X11.
> X11 limitations don't come into play when the app itself does it.
>
> > 3. While this issue was opened against KWin, we users don't care where the
> > solution will land. If it can only be done on the toolkit level (which is
> > probably better than forcing each app/developer to implement it separately),
> > so be it.
> Indeed, that's exactly what Bug 415150 is tracking: having our app framework
> provide the feature automatically for all KDE apps, in the absence of the
> window manager doing it automatically.
>
> Of course time is limited, and here I am responding to comments in a bug
> report instead of writing code. ;)

On my PC even Dolphin, not to mention Discover and Elisa do not remember the last size and placement. But they do on my laptop somehow, despite the configs being IDENTICAL