(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #62)
> (In reply to David Nemeskey from comment #60)
> > 1. Yes, what I described is the lack of the feature in the Gnome / Cinnamon
> > ecosystem as a whole. However, at least some applications (and key
> > applications like Terminal, Synaptic, etc.) do it, which makes it a much
> > more acceptable experience than in KDE (speaking from memory here, but the
> > issue is still open, so...)
> For sure. Similar,y, some KDE applications already support this
> individually, such as Discover and Elisa.
>
> > 2. The fact that some applications do it means it is possible, and was
> > possible even with X11.
> X11 limitations don't come into play when the app itself does it.
>
> > 3. While this issue was opened against KWin, we users don't care where the
> > solution will land. If it can only be done on the toolkit level (which is
> > probably better than forcing each app/developer to implement it separately),
> > so be it.
> Indeed, that's exactly what Bug 415150 is tracking: having our app framework
> provide the feature automatically for all KDE apps, in the absence of the
> window manager doing it automatically.
>
> Of course time is limited, and here I am responding to comments in a bug
> report instead of writing code. ;)
On my PC even Dolphin, not to mention Discover and Elisa do not remember the last size and placement. But they do on my laptop somehow, despite the configs being IDENTICAL
(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #62)
> (In reply to David Nemeskey from comment #60)
> > 1. Yes, what I described is the lack of the feature in the Gnome / Cinnamon
> > ecosystem as a whole. However, at least some applications (and key
> > applications like Terminal, Synaptic, etc.) do it, which makes it a much
> > more acceptable experience than in KDE (speaking from memory here, but the
> > issue is still open, so...)
> For sure. Similar,y, some KDE applications already support this
> individually, such as Discover and Elisa.
>
> > 2. The fact that some applications do it means it is possible, and was
> > possible even with X11.
> X11 limitations don't come into play when the app itself does it.
>
> > 3. While this issue was opened against KWin, we users don't care where the
> > solution will land. If it can only be done on the toolkit level (which is
> > probably better than forcing each app/developer to implement it separately),
> > so be it.
> Indeed, that's exactly what Bug 415150 is tracking: having our app framework
> provide the feature automatically for all KDE apps, in the absence of the
> window manager doing it automatically.
>
> Of course time is limited, and here I am responding to comments in a bug
> report instead of writing code. ;)
On my PC even Dolphin, not to mention Discover and Elisa do not remember the last size and placement. But they do on my laptop somehow, despite the configs being IDENTICAL