Ubuntu
ipmitool package

Bug #2076173
Comment #8

Comment 8 for bug 2076173

Revision history for this message

Joao Andre Simioni (jasimioni) wrote on 2024-08-13:

#8

Early tests with the provided PPA for Jammy worked as expected. Below the report:

We've confirmed successful results with the PPA ipmitool. Previously, the SEL events for SPD_FAN_[1..4]_5 plus SPD_FAN_4_[1..4] were not properly reported. E.g. these IDs for these fans were 0x1a0-0x1a7, and only the lower byte was being used.

# ipmitool -V

ipmitool version 1.8.18

ipmitool sel elist log as below:

| 08/07/2024 | 09:41:47 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:41:47 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4840 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 5720 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:31 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:31 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:00 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3520 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:00 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4224 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:23 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:23 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:58 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3520 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:03 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 5632 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:16 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:37 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3608 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:37 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4312 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:59 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:00 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:34 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3520 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:34 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4136 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:49 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:49 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:09 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3168 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:09 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3608 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:24 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:24 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:46 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3784 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:46 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4400 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:47:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:47:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:48:58 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 2288 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:49:01 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 6424 < Threshold 2464 RPM

Early tests with the provided PPA for Jammy worked as expected. Below the report:

We've confirmed successful results with the PPA ipmitool. Previously, the SEL events for SPD_FAN_[1..4]_5 plus SPD_FAN_4_[1..4] were not properly reported. E.g. these IDs for these fans were 0x1a0-0x1a7, and only the lower byte was being used.

# ipmitool -V

ipmitool version 1.8.18

ipmitool sel elist log as below:

| 08/07/2024 | 09:41:47 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:41:47 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4840 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_1_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 5720 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:31 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:42:31 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:00 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3520 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:00 | Fan SPD_FAN_2_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4224 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:23 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:23 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:43:58 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3520 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:03 | Fan SPD_FAN_3_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 5632 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:16 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:37 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3608 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:37 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_1_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4312 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:44:59 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:00 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:34 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3520 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:34 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_2_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4136 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:49 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:45:49 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:09 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3168 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:09 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_3_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3608 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:24 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:24 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:46 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 3784 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:46:46 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_4_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 4400 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:47:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:47:14 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Asserted | Reading 0 < Threshold 2464 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:48:58 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_R | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 2288 < Threshold 2200 RPM

| 08/07/2024 | 09:49:01 | Fan SPD_FAN_4_5_F | Lower Critical going low | Deasserted | Reading 6424 < Threshold 2464 RPM