No more UI to decide whether receiving file via bluetooth is permitted or not in Intrepid

Bug #290875 reported by Jonathan Ernst on 2008-10-29
34
This bug affects 5 people
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
gnome-user-share (Ubuntu)
Undecided
Unassigned

Bug Description

This is a regression between Hardy and Intrepid

== Regression details ==
Discovered in version: Intrepid
Last known good version: Hardy

== Affected use cases ==
Receiving files via bluetooth

== Known workaround ==
- use Ubuntu Hardy
- use "browse this device" function (note that browsing a device is not the same as being able to receive files from another device)

== Potential future workaround ==
- install and use gnome-user-share, an universe package that depends also on Apache... and that is currently broken (Bug #289487)

== Description ==
In Feisty, the user was forced to install and run an obex server to be able to receive files
In Hardy this was fixed and there were options (always accept files, ask user, never accept files)
In Intrepid there is no more options, so I don't know if my computer is supposed to be able to accept files or not (because of Bug #211252)

Bluetooth is severly broken in Intrepid and there are many regressions (Bug #211252 and Bug #289836 for example)

Jonathan Ernst (jonathan.ernst) wrote :

AFAIK it is now required to install a package from universe (gnome-user-share) to be able to set up bluetooth file reception.

This is really bad as bluetooth file reception is a core feature of bluetooth. I was really happy that bluetooth file reception was easier to set up and working better than on any other OS. Now you have to install packages, (that depend on Apache !).

Daniel James (daniel-netbreeze) wrote :

I can't agree more. I was very happy to recommend ubuntu for laptops as stuff just worked. Now it seems that laptops are getting less and less support under ubuntu. Bluetooth needs to be supported out of the box, a universe package is not intuitive at all. The only way to find out what you are supposed to do to enable bluetooth file reception is to get on bugzilla. This would not work in my parent's case.

Andrea Grandi (andreagrandi) wrote :

I agree with Daniel. I think this is a regression from Ubuntu 8.04.
Maybe I'm able to receive files from my mobile phone, but what if I want to send files TO my mobile phone? Simply, I can't!

Onkar Shinde (onkarshinde) wrote :

@Andrea,

Sending files to phone works same way as it was there in Hardy. Right click any file and select 'Send To ...'. Or right click the bluetooth icon in panel and select 'Send file ...'

The option for receiving file has been removed from UI by upstream authors. Probably they want users to simply use 'Browse' functionality provided by nautilus with gvfs backend.

Daniel James (daniel-netbreeze) wrote :

I hate to think I 'know best' - but the upstream author is wrong. When I'm browsing photos on my phone that I've taken and I want to send a particular picture to the computer, the easiest way to do this is click the little envelope and 'send to' 'silver-0'. Searching through a nasty folder structure to find the name of a file similar to the file I'm viewing is definitely more complicated in this case.

I really really *really* don't want to explain to my parents how to do something like this either. Especially when I was able to demonstrate to friends how easy it was to use linux with my phone a year ago.

Sorry to be a pain :-/

Jonathan Ernst (jonathan.ernst) wrote :

This and if you have another computer in the room and ask your coworker to send you a file it won't work. (And I'm not sure file browsing would work without fiddling with the other user's settings).

description: updated
Nicolò Chieffo (yelo3) wrote :

Jaunty has this problem
There are 2 gconf keys in /apps/bluetooth-gnome but they don't do anything

For files sharing use gnome-user-share.
Closing as INVALID

Changed in bluez-gnome:
status: New → Invalid
To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  Edit
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers