I just rebooted and the bug is no longer there (the button does indeed reboot).
What I also noticed, is that yesterday the "Reboot" button in that dialog was on the left, but now there's a "Suspend" button, and the "Reboot" button is next to it.
I'm thinking I installed something (that introduced that Suspend button) and that's what caused the buttons to temporarily be broken.
I just rebooted and the bug is no longer there (the button does indeed reboot).
What I also noticed, is that yesterday the "Reboot" button in that dialog was on the left, but now there's a "Suspend" button, and the "Reboot" button is next to it.
I'm thinking I installed something (that introduced that Suspend button) and that's what caused the buttons to temporarily be broken.