Comment 8 for bug 890747

Revision history for this message
manny (estelar57) wrote : Re: Ctrl Alt Del doesn't do what most people typing it would expect

funny video :)

>Someone using Ubuntu who types Ctrl Alt Del is far more likely to have previously used Windows than to have previously used Mac OS X

>The point here is not to emulate Windows, but to provide something that people pressing it are likely to be looking for

Valid points, but you're pointing out what "windows users" are expecting.

So in windows (since vista), the behavior is to offer a *few common options*.

Not saying we should offer "all" those options and clone their screen, but most likely the 2 or 3 that "different users" would be expecting.

Else this could become an endless discussion since from memory the behavior of this shortcut in Ubuntu has changed in almost every release...
Someone has always found that it needed to do something different. So maybe providing a dialog with more than one option would be the best solution for the majority.

Am sure microsoft has done quite a good amount of user/enterprise testing for choosing to provide that screen. So imho maybe some user testing would be needed here to offer the best choices.