Comment 8 for bug 315970

Revision history for this message
ThePhilips (thephilips) wrote : Re: g-p-m keeps disk spinning

m4cph1sto, thanks for the information. I - reporter - already have removed g-p-m from my system so couldn't provide the info.

> personally I think this is a bug because this behavior prevents the hard drive from spinning down and thus shortens battery life

Very true.

> and may lead to early hard drive failure.

Not true. HDD are made for constant spinning. They can spin for several many month constantly without problems.
In fact, spin-down & spin-up cycle is limited "resource" and does shorten life of HDDs. Negligibly, yet it does. (I heard laptop HDDs are tested for something like 100K spin-down-spin-up cycles.)

But of course in context of laptops, this is clear bug.

My personal problems are: battery life and heat. In fact, I'd say heat is bigger issue than battery life. As hard drive spins constantly, my notebook (namely the part where HDD is) heats up so much that I cannot keep it on my lap anymore.