Comment 2 for bug 255255

Revision history for this message
Theodore Ts'o (tytso) wrote :

Can you send me the first 64k of the device? i.e.:

sudo dd if=/dev/sdb5 of=/tmp/jfs.img bs=64k count=1

And then upload /tmp/jfs.img

I have no doubt that moving the JFS-related entry before the VFAT entry will solve the problem, but the probe_fat_nomagic() does a lot of tests before concluding that the filesystem is VFAT. This leads me to believe that /dev/sdb5 was previously formatted as VFAT, and the JFS mkfs didn't do enough to eradicate the traces of the old VFAT partition. The problem is that there is a much weaker test for JFS, so this could lead to false positives in the other direction. (i.e., a JFS filesystem which is then formatted to be a VFAT partition.) So I'd like to get a copy of the beginning of the filesystem to see if there's a better fix.

My guess is the other problem is that mkfs.jfs needs to do a better job wiping out the first few kilobytes of the image to prevent this kind of false positive.