Please read the "REPORTING BUGS" section of the e2fsck man page. I need to know exactly what sort of inconsistencies were reported by e2fsck. Also, are you sure that /dev/hda5 on your new installation of Feisty is the same as on the other installation of Feisty? You might want to run dumpe2fs and look at the UUID and make sure it really is the filesystem that you think it is. Sometimes different kernels will autodetect different disks in different orders, and /dev/hda is just the first disk detected by the kernel.
Please read the "REPORTING BUGS" section of the e2fsck man page. I need to know exactly what sort of inconsistencies were reported by e2fsck. Also, are you sure that /dev/hda5 on your new installation of Feisty is the same as on the other installation of Feisty? You might want to run dumpe2fs and look at the UUID and make sure it really is the filesystem that you think it is. Sometimes different kernels will autodetect different disks in different orders, and /dev/hda is just the first disk detected by the kernel.