Comment 2 for bug 1638428

Some relevant logs when running the overcloud deploy command with --debug

Environment directory: environments-ssl
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/01-puppet-pacemaker.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/02-network-isolation.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/03-ips-from-pool-all.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/04-storage-environment.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/05-enable-tls.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/06-tls-endpoints-public-dns.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/10-nuclab-host-definitions.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/11-nuclab-storage-environment.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/12-nuclab-network-environment.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/13-nuclab-customisations.yaml
Environment directory file: environments-ssl/14-nuclab-enable-ssl.yaml
Processing environment files ['/home/stack/overcloud-env.json', u'environments-ssl/01-puppet-pacemaker.yaml', u'environments-ssl/02-network-isolation.yaml', u'environments-ssl/03-ips-from-pool-all.yaml', u'environments-ssl/04-storage-environment.yaml', u'environments-ssl/05-enable-tls.yaml', u'environments-ssl/06-tls-endpoints-public-dns.yaml', u'environments-ssl/10-nuclab-host-definitions.yaml', u'environments-ssl/11-nuclab-storage-environment.yaml', u'environments-ssl/12-nuclab-network-environment.yaml', u'environments-ssl/13-nuclab-customisations.yaml', u'environments-ssl/14-nuclab-enable-ssl.yaml']
Processing environment files /home/stack/overcloud-env.json
Processing environment files environments-ssl/01-puppet-pacemaker.yaml
Error Could not fetch contents for file:///home/stack/nuclab-tripleo/openstack-deployment/puppet/services/pacemaker/rabbitmq.yaml processing environment file environments-ssl/01-puppet-pacemaker.yaml
Rewriting environments-ssl/01-puppet-pacemaker.yaml environment to /tmp/tripleoclient-NgU9zS/tripleo-heat-templates/env-haproxy-Eqxtrc.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/02-network-isolation.yaml
Error Could not fetch contents for file:///home/stack/nuclab-tripleo/openstack-deployment/network/ports/internal_api.yaml processing environment file environments-ssl/02-network-isolation.yaml
Rewriting environments-ssl/02-network-isolation.yaml environment to /tmp/tripleoclient-NgU9zS/tripleo-heat-templates/env-noop-jgHLkX.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/03-ips-from-pool-all.yaml
Error Could not fetch contents for file:///home/stack/nuclab-tripleo/openstack-deployment/network/ports/noop.yaml processing environment file environments-ssl/03-ips-from-pool-all.yaml
Rewriting environments-ssl/03-ips-from-pool-all.yaml environment to /tmp/tripleoclient-NgU9zS/tripleo-heat-templates/env-storage_from_pool-QT9JSS.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/04-storage-environment.yaml
Error Could not fetch contents for file:///home/stack/nuclab-tripleo/openstack-deployment/puppet/services/ceph-client.yaml processing environment file environments-ssl/04-storage-environment.yaml
Rewriting environments-ssl/04-storage-environment.yaml environment to /tmp/tripleoclient-NgU9zS/tripleo-heat-templates/env-ceph-mon-UXWcV_.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/05-enable-tls.yaml
Error Could not fetch contents for file:///home/stack/nuclab-tripleo/openstack-deployment/puppet/extraconfig/tls/tls-cert-inject.yaml processing environment file environments-ssl/05-enable-tls.yaml
Rewriting environments-ssl/05-enable-tls.yaml environment to /tmp/tripleoclient-NgU9zS/tripleo-heat-templates/env-tls-cert-inject-qKlVUZ.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/06-tls-endpoints-public-dns.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/10-nuclab-host-definitions.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/11-nuclab-storage-environment.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/12-nuclab-network-environment.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/13-nuclab-customisations.yaml
Processing environment files environments-ssl/14-nuclab-enable-ssl.yaml

You can see that the environment registry part of the symlinked environment files doesn't get populated as the paths the files is referencing is wrong. This is the same if I copy the files in directly from templates.

However, if I copy the files in from templates, then edit their resource registries to have the right path, it works.

I think this needs to be changed to be more intelligent if we hope to have people use --environment-directory and existing environment files from tht. Also we could do with better error message (and the deploy failing) when this problem occurs, instead of attempting to do the deploy with the files not included leading to inconsistent and confusing results.