OpenContrail

Network policies failed to attach to a network using simultaneous Heat stack-update operations

Bug #1507501 reported by Eswar
8
This bug affects 1 person
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
Juniper Openstack
Status tracked in Trunk
R2.20
Fix Committed
High
Prakash Bailkeri
Juniper Openstack r2.22
R2.21.x
Fix Committed
High
Prakash Bailkeri
Juniper Openstack r2.21.1
Trunk
Fix Committed
High
Prakash Bailkeri
Juniper Openstack r3.0-fcs
OpenContrail
New
High
Prakash Bailkeri

Bug Description

I am doing simultaneous heat stack-update operations.
As a part of stack-update, we create a policy and attach policy to left-network and right-network.

But around 5-10 policies are not getting associated to right-network during 60 heat stack-update operations.
As per HOT template, left-net is a newly created resource and right-net is a parameter (already existing resource).

root@nfv-server04:~# contrail-version
Package Version Build-ID | Repo | Package Name
-------------------------------------- ------------------------------ ----------------------------------
contrail-analytics 2.21-102 102
contrail-config 2.21-102 102

root@nfv-server04:~# heat resource-list jsm-45273b9b-583f-4e15-be8e-4205e1a4c937
+--------------------+-------------------------------+-----------------+----------------------+
| resource_name | resource_type | resource_status | updated_time |
+--------------------+-------------------------------+-----------------+----------------------+
| left-net | OS::Contrail::VirtualNetwork | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:37:44Z |
| vFF-0-vnf-flavor | OS::JSM::GetFlavor | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:37:44Z |
| vFF-0-vnf-template | OS::Contrail::ServiceTemplate | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:37:45Z |
| left-subnet | OS::Neutron::Subnet | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:37:46Z |
| vFF-0-vnf-instance | OS::Contrail::ServiceInstance | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:37:49Z |
| site-access-policy | OS::Contrail::NetworkPolicy | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:54:26Z |
| ns-entry | OS::Contrail::AttachPolicy | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:54:27Z |
| ns-exit | OS::Contrail::AttachPolicy | CREATE_COMPLETE | 2015-10-19T05:54:27Z |
+--------------------+-------------------------------+-----------------+----------------------+

  ns-entry: <<<<<< attaches policy to left-net

=================================
    depends_on: [left-net, site-access-policy]
    properties:
      network: {get_resource: left-net}
      policy:
        get_attr: [site-access-policy, fq_name]
    type: OS::Contrail::AttachPolicy

  ns-exit: <<<<<< attaches policy to right-net

========================== =======
    depends_on: [site-access-policy]
    properties:
      network: {get_param: right-net-id}
      policy:
        get_attr: [site-access-policy, fq_name]
    type: OS::Contrail::AttachPolicy

  site-access-policy:
=================================
    depends_on: [left-net, vFF-0-vnf-instance]
    properties:
      entries:
        policy_rule:
        - action_list:
            apply_service:
            - {get_resource: vFF-0-vnf-instance}
          direction: <>
          dst_addresses:
          - virtual_network: {get_param: right-net-id}
          dst_ports:
          - {end_port: -1, start_port: -1}
          protocol: any
          src_addresses:
          - virtual_network: {get_resource: left-net}
          src_ports:
          - {end_port: -1, start_port: -1}
      name:
        Fn::Join:
        - '-'
        - - {get_param: nsid}
          - cb9e2ff7-0683-4e8f-8c44-d3b23c055ffe-site-access-policy
    type: OS::Contrail::NetworkPolicy

In Contrail GUI:
==============

For attached-failed policy:
=======================

Display Name
0689a692-7f45-47af-8c68-ce342339c4b9-7f2ecc86-0472-4ed4-bc6f-ff95aad6c60a-site-access-policy

UUID
5122d08c-fce2-42f4-8f6a-6f7239f7aac3

Associated Networks
45273b9b-583f-4e15-be8e-4205e1a4c937-left-net

Rules
pass protocol any network 0689a692-7f45-47af-8c68-ce342339c4b9-left-net ports any <> network right-net ports any services 0689a692-7f45-47af-8c68-ce342339c4b9-vFF-0-vnf-instance

For attached-success policy:
=======================
Display Name
e4c0e411-2dc7-4440-af16-cf813f3f1df2-49eac946-5f5b-43df-8223-1244e9ae9356-site-access-policy

UUID
4ec75a6f-e300-43e9-b626-9fab0117adbb

Associated Networks
right-net
e4c0e411-2dc7-4440-af16-cf813f3f1df2-left-net

Rules
pass protocol any network e4c0e411-2dc7-4440-af16-cf813f3f1df2-left-net ports any <> network right-net ports any services e4c0e411-2dc7-4440-af16-cf813f3f1df2-vFF-0-vnf-instance

From contrail-logs:
==================

VNC config API server trying to add 0689a692-7f45-47af-8c68-ce342339c4b9-7f2ecc86-0472-4ed4-bc6f-ff95aad6c60a-site-access-policy to 29th sequence.

But e9f19e97-0596-43d6-b9b9-59327552b0f7-be4ae337-5068-4e60-8dc9-ad10530bba85-site-access-policy got added to 29th sequence.

So my suspicion is 0689a692-7f45-47af-8c68-ce342339c4b9-7f2ecc86-0472-4ed4-bc6f-ff95aad6c60a-site-access-policy not getting attched to right-netwok.

2015 Oct 18 20:27:42.536410 nfv-server04 [:contrail-api:] : VncApiConfigLog: [VncApiCommon: identifier_uuid = 904b3ebd-bc94-4fd3-8087-69a728b02c4c, object_type = virtual_network, identifier_name = default-domain:admin:right-net, url = http://127.0.0.1:9100/virtual-network/904b3ebd-bc94-4fd3-8087-69a728b02c4c, operation = put, useragent = nfv-server04:/usr/bin/contrail-api, remote_ip = 127.0.0.1:9100, body = {'virtual-network': {'uuid': '904b3ebd-bc94-4fd3-8087-69a728b02c4c', 'network_policy_refs': [{'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'a507be3a-9279-4122-8720-30e9cb3091c4-9f81d4e3-eb19-4faa-bccd-6b6cacd654ea-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 0, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '8a73c4db-2387-4e0e-b558-86d37676a96e-ba115934-c181-4a07-ac21-eef57efec135-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 1, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'ede97471-94e3-4534-8bbf-e836c762d4ef-ca8cad49-5225-4628-842c-913e9a337ec4-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 2, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '91eeca46-6fb7-4581-86a6-d474dd98b088-95dc9444-f7d6-4271-9e13-d51382f26926-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 3, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '5245dcc0-c356-47a5-ba28-8820e240fa69-cc999275-6864-4de9-98ec-a92c7cf556ba-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 4, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '7c9f9a19-1ab4-4849-96d8-7eb6f0b7beeb-cb1ae85f-1bf6-48f8-9f22-773844cf3369-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 5, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '1c601eaa-617d-45e9-9f67-a8dbf3123d4b-c9ea864e-556d-4ae0-ba48-a50cba3d8607-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 6, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'b438e2ce-b125-45c4-ae8f-8a4d8e1d0f33-75bd8e5f-8d09-49df-bab2-ceee8a7189b6-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 7, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'ebcaff3a-ba94-4ac4-9a7f-ecd161e2e12e-3667a6c6-b671-42b5-a2ce-d215ebcbc063-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 8, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'd1318baa-3449-43e9-831d-d498015b9322-65672917-bd2b-400d-bb32-a21c46f941d8-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 9, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '848ebb34-9c26-462c-ab07-76939704ac9b-19b3448b-44af-41a9-998b-42c2cdcbbc22-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 10, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'e9d5f2cd-67bb-4322-82dc-c5fcde4a5ae8-00efd5b1-4953-4559-a5b2-8e43b55edde5-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 11, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '170808fc-ca22-4248-a001-280cb0161faf-26dce628-77a9-44a1-8bf7-9c8db689a491-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 12, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '4738af44-302a-4411-9ac8-fc9d444a6b21-668a4e7c-9908-4940-ab5c-8044739f40e2-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 13, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '2077770f-a75b-4f13-9c96-93ee4bab8922-745b058d-9f0b-4c10-9622-b6d27821bab8-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 14, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'b1d33544-8bf7-4556-801e-cd5250955822-21d60a88-da72-4bcd-9bcc-b0d658dbd592-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 15, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '4d678791-7a3a-4bdb-add9-a5e5cefa981c-1036475d-2136-4766-b9b7-f6de74d0e503-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 16, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'f487d81c-544d-4fda-aa7e-bdbc0bbbb03d-bf15ca3e-8e6e-4b29-9105-b4062ac429a7-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 17, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'fe6a9e51-d7ef-42ce-bfd3-8ff4aa2225af-3a59a4e3-5cf1-4e34-b5ef-dc7e531ddbf5-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 18, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'd81b8f8d-016a-44ff-960b-7741ae39cf38-2b1f45ca-de45-4919-8d65-6d7c119d083c-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 19, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '4dea9c68-6ca7-4056-aad3-36a1aacd4566-f7e3aeba-49b0-47cd-ab22-7dcd36983719-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 20, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '2d811420-066a-4aad-9b51-1b57024e2d96-7b9fa042-8914-42c8-80e8-50771672a301-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 21, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '6339d193-e42b-4c3f-aa80-d5706af8724a-889b15a7-056b-4180-9b45-b77eb40736bb-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 22, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '89950e6c-0ec7-4f07-b66c-a814d561af2e-27b82441-b60c-4151-921f-7fb8f1c482b8-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 23, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'aa0a6fc1-da56-4276-89e8-dc481113bdcf-0234a275-7629-46a4-aec8-e8360203c2fd-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 24, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '2745378c-2de4-4396-95a2-bf347978115f-b4593ce8-4d79-4202-afb6-bea45b1a685f-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 25, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '3993195f-27d3-445f-a4c4-098af5fc5a17-601c1fec-627b-414c-98b7-16a6544b9fbf-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 26, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '67e023eb-5175-4d62-9aae-37b29a4c6c43-519ca04f-7493-48ce-ad21-6e1fc3918344-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 27, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '044b3b2d-add8-47ab-8991-4d6ffd7de92c-98e8fe46-22d6-4e8c-8ebf-707ae0486fb4-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 28, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '0689a692-7f45-47af-8c68-ce342339c4b9-7f2ecc86-0472-4ed4-bc6f-ff95aad6c60a-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 29, 'minor': 0}}}]}}, domain = default-domain, project = admin, user = admin]

2015 Oct 18 20:28:46.753706 nfv-server04 [:contrail-api:] : VncApiConfigLog: [VncApiCommon: identifier_uuid = 904b3ebd-bc94-4fd3-8087-69a728b02c4c, object_type = virtual_network, identifier_name = default-domain:admin:right-net, url = http://127.0.0.1:9100/virtual-network/904b3ebd-bc94-4fd3-8087-69a728b02c4c, operation = put, useragent = nfv-server04:/usr/bin/contrail-api, remote_ip = 127.0.0.1:9100, body = {'virtual-network': {'uuid': '904b3ebd-bc94-4fd3-8087-69a728b02c4c', 'network_policy_refs': [{'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'a507be3a-9279-4122-8720-30e9cb3091c4-9f81d4e3-eb19-4faa-bccd-6b6cacd654ea-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 0, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '8a73c4db-2387-4e0e-b558-86d37676a96e-ba115934-c181-4a07-ac21-eef57efec135-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 1, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'ede97471-94e3-4534-8bbf-e836c762d4ef-ca8cad49-5225-4628-842c-913e9a337ec4-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 2, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '91eeca46-6fb7-4581-86a6-d474dd98b088-95dc9444-f7d6-4271-9e13-d51382f26926-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 3, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '5245dcc0-c356-47a5-ba28-8820e240fa69-cc999275-6864-4de9-98ec-a92c7cf556ba-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 4, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '7c9f9a19-1ab4-4849-96d8-7eb6f0b7beeb-cb1ae85f-1bf6-48f8-9f22-773844cf3369-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 5, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '1c601eaa-617d-45e9-9f67-a8dbf3123d4b-c9ea864e-556d-4ae0-ba48-a50cba3d8607-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 6, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'b438e2ce-b125-45c4-ae8f-8a4d8e1d0f33-75bd8e5f-8d09-49df-bab2-ceee8a7189b6-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 7, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'ebcaff3a-ba94-4ac4-9a7f-ecd161e2e12e-3667a6c6-b671-42b5-a2ce-d215ebcbc063-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 8, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'd1318baa-3449-43e9-831d-d498015b9322-65672917-bd2b-400d-bb32-a21c46f941d8-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 9, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '848ebb34-9c26-462c-ab07-76939704ac9b-19b3448b-44af-41a9-998b-42c2cdcbbc22-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 10, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'e9d5f2cd-67bb-4322-82dc-c5fcde4a5ae8-00efd5b1-4953-4559-a5b2-8e43b55edde5-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 11, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '170808fc-ca22-4248-a001-280cb0161faf-26dce628-77a9-44a1-8bf7-9c8db689a491-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 12, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '4738af44-302a-4411-9ac8-fc9d444a6b21-668a4e7c-9908-4940-ab5c-8044739f40e2-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 13, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '2077770f-a75b-4f13-9c96-93ee4bab8922-745b058d-9f0b-4c10-9622-b6d27821bab8-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 14, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'b1d33544-8bf7-4556-801e-cd5250955822-21d60a88-da72-4bcd-9bcc-b0d658dbd592-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 15, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '4d678791-7a3a-4bdb-add9-a5e5cefa981c-1036475d-2136-4766-b9b7-f6de74d0e503-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 16, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'f487d81c-544d-4fda-aa7e-bdbc0bbbb03d-bf15ca3e-8e6e-4b29-9105-b4062ac429a7-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 17, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'fe6a9e51-d7ef-42ce-bfd3-8ff4aa2225af-3a59a4e3-5cf1-4e34-b5ef-dc7e531ddbf5-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 18, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'd81b8f8d-016a-44ff-960b-7741ae39cf38-2b1f45ca-de45-4919-8d65-6d7c119d083c-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 19, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '4dea9c68-6ca7-4056-aad3-36a1aacd4566-f7e3aeba-49b0-47cd-ab22-7dcd36983719-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 20, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '2d811420-066a-4aad-9b51-1b57024e2d96-7b9fa042-8914-42c8-80e8-50771672a301-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 21, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '6339d193-e42b-4c3f-aa80-d5706af8724a-889b15a7-056b-4180-9b45-b77eb40736bb-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 22, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '89950e6c-0ec7-4f07-b66c-a814d561af2e-27b82441-b60c-4151-921f-7fb8f1c482b8-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 23, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'aa0a6fc1-da56-4276-89e8-dc481113bdcf-0234a275-7629-46a4-aec8-e8360203c2fd-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 24, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '2745378c-2de4-4396-95a2-bf347978115f-b4593ce8-4d79-4202-afb6-bea45b1a685f-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 25, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '3993195f-27d3-445f-a4c4-098af5fc5a17-601c1fec-627b-414c-98b7-16a6544b9fbf-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 26, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '67e023eb-5175-4d62-9aae-37b29a4c6c43-519ca04f-7493-48ce-ad21-6e1fc3918344-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 27, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '044b3b2d-add8-47ab-8991-4d6ffd7de92c-98e8fe46-22d6-4e8c-8ebf-707ae0486fb4-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 28, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', 'e9f19e97-0596-43d6-b9b9-59327552b0f7-be4ae337-5068-4e60-8dc9-ad10530bba85-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 29, 'minor': 0}}}, {'to': ['default-domain', 'admin', '88108b5a-cf7a-4538-83a8-e967699a412f-8c24dfd7-0b0e-4e9d-80f9-385ecb9294c1-site-access-policy'], 'attr': {'timer': None, 'sequence': {'major': 30, 'minor': 0}}}]}}, domain = default-domain, project = admin, user = admin]

Tags: config heat
Revision history for this message
Prakash Bailkeri (prakashmb) wrote :

Heat resource implementation for attach_policy fetches the existing policy and appends the new policy.

In race condition, attach_policy overwrites the previously added network policy on VN.

Solution: Use ref_update ADD/DELETE to add new network policy or remove the network policy.

Changed in opencontrail:
assignee: nobody → Prakash Bailkeri (prakashmb)
importance: Undecided → High
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f)
tags: added: config heat
Revision history for this message
Praneet Bachheti (praneetb) wrote :

ETA - 11/6

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : [Review update] master

Review in progress for https://review.opencontrail.org/14925
Submitter: Prakash Bailkeri (<email address hidden>)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : A change has been merged

Reviewed: https://review.opencontrail.org/14925
Committed: http://github.org/Juniper/contrail-heat/commit/b0ea746d612e0057e22d0b323d79350448b0aa09
Submitter: Zuul
Branch: master

commit b0ea746d612e0057e22d0b323d79350448b0aa09
Author: Prakash Bailkeri <email address hidden>
Date: Thu Nov 5 21:30:12 2015 -0800

Network policy attach heat resource enhancements

1. Make this resource as ContrailResource
2. Use ref-update api to ensure that only new policy add/delete operation is
performed.
3. Define new parameter which defines the order in which new policy is inserted

Change-Id: I92449b974eedcf60ed016fc2f052f41aa09f8ea8
Closes-bug: #1507501

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : [Review update] master

Review in progress for https://review.opencontrail.org/14970
Submitter: Prakash Bailkeri (<email address hidden>)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : A change has been merged

Reviewed: https://review.opencontrail.org/14970
Committed: http://github.org/Juniper/contrail-heat/commit/b9a803b05d42ff0985c35dab6b23bf931b559890
Submitter: Zuul
Branch: master

commit b9a803b05d42ff0985c35dab6b23bf931b559890
Author: Prakash M Bailkeri <email address hidden>
Date: Mon Nov 9 10:13:18 2015 +0530

Example template for network policy attach resource with sequence

1. add example template for both default sequence and user defined sequence
2. Update the parameter file

Change-Id: Ie99d5c395ce9815066f33fb42056e654e70c1377
Closes-bug: #1507501

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : [Review update] R2.20

Review in progress for https://review.opencontrail.org/15097
Submitter: Prakash Bailkeri (<email address hidden>)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote :

Review in progress for https://review.opencontrail.org/15098
Submitter: Prakash Bailkeri (<email address hidden>)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : A change has been merged

Reviewed: https://review.opencontrail.org/15097
Committed: http://github.org/Juniper/contrail-heat/commit/9213019fbd05a4f35f29c8793bb0305a9b8e086f
Submitter: Zuul
Branch: R2.20

commit 9213019fbd05a4f35f29c8793bb0305a9b8e086f
Author: Prakash Bailkeri <email address hidden>
Date: Thu Nov 5 21:30:12 2015 -0800

Network policy attach heat resource enhancements

1. Make this resource as ContrailResource
2. Use ref-update api to ensure that only new policy add/delete operation is
performed.
3. Define new parameter which defines the order in which new policy is inserted

Change-Id: I92449b974eedcf60ed016fc2f052f41aa09f8ea8
Closes-bug: #1507501
(cherry picked from commit b0ea746d612e0057e22d0b323d79350448b0aa09)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote :

Reviewed: https://review.opencontrail.org/15098
Committed: http://github.org/Juniper/contrail-heat/commit/551f352120c15567173cf61bdcd4806b56cc5b99
Submitter: Zuul
Branch: R2.20

commit 551f352120c15567173cf61bdcd4806b56cc5b99
Author: Prakash M Bailkeri <email address hidden>
Date: Mon Nov 9 10:13:18 2015 +0530

Example template for network policy attach resource with sequence

1. add example template for both default sequence and user defined sequence
2. Update the parameter file

Change-Id: Ie99d5c395ce9815066f33fb42056e654e70c1377
Closes-bug: #1507501
(cherry picked from commit b9a803b05d42ff0985c35dab6b23bf931b559890)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : [Review update] R2.21.x

Review in progress for https://review.opencontrail.org/15452
Submitter: Vinay Vithal Mahuli (<email address hidden>)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote :

Review in progress for https://review.opencontrail.org/15453
Submitter: Vinay Vithal Mahuli (<email address hidden>)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote : A change has been merged

Reviewed: https://review.opencontrail.org/15452
Committed: http://github.org/Juniper/contrail-heat/commit/bbcda78b3e31c5eb5223c0d42261c68ac945090d
Submitter: Zuul
Branch: R2.21.x

commit bbcda78b3e31c5eb5223c0d42261c68ac945090d
Author: Prakash Bailkeri <email address hidden>
Date: Thu Nov 5 21:30:12 2015 -0800

Network policy attach heat resource enhancements

1. Make this resource as ContrailResource
2. Use ref-update api to ensure that only new policy add/delete operation is
performed.
3. Define new parameter which defines the order in which new policy is inserted

Change-Id: I92449b974eedcf60ed016fc2f052f41aa09f8ea8
Closes-bug: #1507501
(cherry picked from commit b0ea746d612e0057e22d0b323d79350448b0aa09)

Revision history for this message
OpenContrail Admin (ci-admin-f) wrote :

Reviewed: https://review.opencontrail.org/15453
Committed: http://github.org/Juniper/contrail-heat/commit/504a0e70264bcceed1dae62dd38d49082bc4ca40
Submitter: Zuul
Branch: R2.21.x

commit 504a0e70264bcceed1dae62dd38d49082bc4ca40
Author: Prakash M Bailkeri <email address hidden>
Date: Mon Nov 9 10:13:18 2015 +0530

Example template for network policy attach resource with sequence

1. add example template for both default sequence and user defined sequence
2. Update the parameter file

Change-Id: Ie99d5c395ce9815066f33fb42056e654e70c1377
Closes-bug: #1507501
(cherry picked from commit b9a803b05d42ff0985c35dab6b23bf931b559890)

Revision history for this message
Mohammad Talha Omer (mohammadtalhaomer) wrote :

Hi Everyone,

Can you please let me know why we need major and minor sequence in heat template as i know sequence numbers are basically the order of policy which defines the position where policy needs to be inserted. So can you please tell me what are the significance and concept of major and minor value.

Regards,

Mohammad Talha Omer

To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.
Subscribing...

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.