Comment 48 for bug 438136

@Daniele Napolitano: I don't understand, you say that SeaTools reads the same data as Palimpsest (S.M.A.R.T. params) and does the same tests. But if that's the case why doesn't SeaTools tell me my drive is failing too?

The drive manufacturer's software isn't showing any problems on my drive, but palimpsest is. Are you saying the bug is in SeaTools?

What would be another good tool to run to get a third opinion?