Comment 3 for bug 1540534

Aaron, the options you put on bug #1567138 seem to complicate things very much because you'll have to check in too many places whether for comment moderation and have to make more choices. I'd suggest that when artefact comments are allowed, they follow the same moderation principles as the page itself. Only when artefact comments are not allowed, nobody can comment no matter whether page comments are allowed or not.

I often set artefact comments to "No" for decorative images or images where I don't want any comments, e.g. a logo. Thus, the "No comments" setting should be respected.

Of course, if we moderate comments on one page but not another, comments could be placed directly, but that would be ok because some people would be exempted from the moderation queue.