Comment 39 for bug 1419355

Revision history for this message
In , dashing.meng (dashing.meng-linux-kernel-bugs) wrote :

(In reply to Takashi Iwai from comment #22)
> (In reply to littlebat from comment #20)
> > As Takashi Iwai said: "this should be a rare case, so we may ignore for
> > now...", if both Linux kernel and Asrock think this is a rare case(for this
> > asrock motherboard, they support Windows officially, so Linux user is a
> rare
> > case). Then, the common user will get a unnormal system.
>
> The rare case mentioned there is that the system goes shutdown after
> xhci_hcd module is unloaded manually. Usually xhci_hcd module stays loaded,
> or it's not loaded at all.
>
> For fixing the shutdown hang after module unload, we'd need yet another
> quirk; this is another BIOS bug, after all. What I said is that such a new
> quirk won't be needed urgently because unloading xhci_hcd doesn't happen
> often in normal operations.
>
> (And we know that it's not a rare case that people don't read the context
> carefully before starting rants ;)

Sorry, I misunderstood your meaning. I don't distinguish very clearly between shutdown with xhci_hcd loaded and unloaded.

Thanks for all of your work. No current Linux if no your effort.