Comment 13 for bug 39547

On Fri, 2006-01-12 at 19:27 +0000, Diogo Matsubara wrote:

> if you have already signed 1.0 you don't need to sign 1.0.1; it's just a
> minor textual update. That's why you're not prompted to sign it again.

Diego, I realize that it is a minor textual update and that my signature is not necessary: As noted in my Q, I wanted to test if this bug (39547) had been resolved, since a) it is marked as 'Fix Released', and b) there have been no updates recently to suggest that the fix "took".

I agree that it is not necessary for me to re-sign; refer to my comments in https://launchpad.net/products/launchpad/+bug/3952/comments/13

However, I would suggest that the lack of indication to this effect is itself a bug! The page that indicates I've signed the CoC indicates that a new CoC is available, and gives me a URL to 'read or sign new version', but then does not give me any opportunity to do so. This is very confusing (I can read it, I can download, where's the upload button?), hence my Q.

There are really only 3 correct options: 1) the "congrats, you've signed the CoC page" should say "There is a new CoC, but the changes are editorial only, you do not need to re-sign. Click here to review the changes for your own peace of mind"; 2) the "read and sign new version" page can say "changes are editorial only, you do not need to re-sign. Click here to review the changes for your own peace of mind"; or 3) the user can be allowed to sign the new version, for their own peace of mind.

Of course, #3 requires that this bug be fixed....