Activity log for bug #1703119

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2017-07-08 15:18:45 Evan Shultz bug added bug
2017-07-08 15:19:14 Evan Shultz attachment added zone_net_names1.PNG https://bugs.launchpad.net/kicad/+bug/1703119/+attachment/4911313/+files/zone_net_names1.PNG
2017-07-08 15:19:31 Evan Shultz attachment added zone_net_names2.PNG https://bugs.launchpad.net/kicad/+bug/1703119/+attachment/4911314/+files/zone_net_names2.PNG
2017-07-08 15:20:29 Evan Shultz description This is a wishlist feature. Especially on 4-layer+ boards, many layers have be completely a ground plane or a power plane. Some layers may be used for power distribution, and have a 5V zone in one area, a 3.3V zone in another area, 1.8V in another area, etc. What would be handy, when initially laying down the zones or during a review, is to quickly see the net connection of the zones while also seeing the entire board. Typically, when fully zoomed out the net names on tracks cannot be seen so the net connectivity of zones cannot be determined. I'm proposing that net name text is shown inside the zone outline, similar to how it's shown on tracks. The text size should scale along with the zoom level, so the text is large enough to read easily regardless of the viewport (of course the text shouldn't grow outside the zone boundary). Also, for large zones it may make sense to show the net name text in a few different places (on some type of grid) so the eye doesn't need to hunt around for the text on any given zone; this is most important if the zone is snake-list instead of a large block. I've attached an example of what this looks like in another PCB design tool. Being able to select a highlight color for nets would also help with this. This is a wishlist feature. Especially on 4-layer+ boards, many layers have be completely a ground plane or a power plane. Some layers may be used for power distribution, and have a 5V zone in one area, a 3.3V zone in another area, 1.8V in another area, etc. What would be handy, when initially laying down the zones or during a review, is to quickly see the net connection of the zones while also seeing the entire board. Typically, when fully zoomed out the net names on tracks cannot be seen so the net connectivity of zones cannot be determined. I'm proposing that net name text is shown inside the zone outline, similar to how it's shown on tracks. The text size should scale along with the zoom level, so the text is large enough to read easily regardless of the viewport (of course the text shouldn't grow outside the zone boundary). Also, for large zones it may make sense to show the net name text in a few different places (on some type of grid) so the eye doesn't need to hunt around for the text on any given zone; this is most important if the zone is snake-list instead of a large block. I'll provide two examples of what this could look like. Being able to select a highlight color for nets would also help with this.
2017-07-08 15:21:29 Evan Shultz description This is a wishlist feature. Especially on 4-layer+ boards, many layers have be completely a ground plane or a power plane. Some layers may be used for power distribution, and have a 5V zone in one area, a 3.3V zone in another area, 1.8V in another area, etc. What would be handy, when initially laying down the zones or during a review, is to quickly see the net connection of the zones while also seeing the entire board. Typically, when fully zoomed out the net names on tracks cannot be seen so the net connectivity of zones cannot be determined. I'm proposing that net name text is shown inside the zone outline, similar to how it's shown on tracks. The text size should scale along with the zoom level, so the text is large enough to read easily regardless of the viewport (of course the text shouldn't grow outside the zone boundary). Also, for large zones it may make sense to show the net name text in a few different places (on some type of grid) so the eye doesn't need to hunt around for the text on any given zone; this is most important if the zone is snake-list instead of a large block. I'll provide two examples of what this could look like. Being able to select a highlight color for nets would also help with this. This is a wishlist feature. Especially on 4-layer+ boards, many layers have be completely a ground plane or a power plane. Some layers may be used for power distribution, and have a 5V zone in one area, a 3.3V zone in another area, 1.8V in another area, etc. What would be handy, when initially laying down the zones or during a review, is to quickly see the net connection of the zones while also seeing the entire board. Typically, when fully zoomed out the net names on tracks cannot be seen so the net connectivity of zones cannot be determined. I'm proposing that net name text is shown inside the zone outline, similar to how it's shown on tracks. The text size should scale along with the zoom level, so the text is large enough to read easily regardless of the viewport (of course the text shouldn't grow outside the zone boundary). Also, for large zones it may make sense to show the net name text in a few different places (on some type of grid) so the eye doesn't need to hunt around for the text on any given zone; this is most important if the zone is snake-list instead of a large block. I'll provide two examples of what this could look like, though admittedly the text is often clipped here so a better implementation may be possible. Being able to select a highlight color for nets would also help with this.
2017-07-10 09:19:40 Tomasz Wlostowski kicad: importance Undecided Wishlist
2019-03-25 23:00:24 Michael Kavanagh tags pcbnew
2019-07-28 12:55:57 Michael Kavanagh kicad: status New Triaged
2021-10-09 22:20:57 KiCad Janitor bug watch added https://gitlab.com/kicad/code/kicad/-/issues/2065
2021-10-09 22:21:00 KiCad Janitor kicad: status Triaged Expired
2021-10-09 22:21:00 KiCad Janitor kicad: remote watch gitlab.com/kicad/code/kicad/-/issues #2065
2022-08-02 22:43:07 Bug Watch Updater kicad: status Expired New
2022-08-02 22:43:07 Bug Watch Updater kicad: importance Wishlist Unknown