Activity log for bug #1516244

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2015-11-14 14:00:43 Joan bug added bug
2015-11-14 14:00:43 Joan attachment added KiCAD_ZonesSetbackEdgeCut_screenshots-for-0.5-and-0.05mm-setbacks.zip https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1516244/+attachment/4518792/+files/KiCAD_ZonesSetbackEdgeCut_screenshots-for-0.5-and-0.05mm-setbacks.zip
2015-11-14 14:05:59 Joan description tested and confirmed in: KiCAD BZR 6097, in module pcbnew KiCAD 4.0.0 RC1, in module pcbnew A copper pour zone that goes to/over a board outside definition has a clearance setting which allows to define a clear space between the board edge and the copper pour. The board edge is defined as the center of the graphic lines on the edge.cuts layer. The problem is that the zone fill clearance setting doesn't use the center of the edge.cuts graphics lines, but the edge of those lines that is closest to it (madworm: I suspect the code doesn't care what object is in the way, be it a track or line). For screenshots and more see this link on KiCAD.info: https://forum.kicad.info/t/zone-setback-influenced-by-edgecut-line-thickness-why/1690 tested and confirmed in: KiCAD BZR 6097, in module pcbnew KiCAD 4.0.0 RC1, in module pcbnew A copper pour zone that goes to/over a board outside definition has a clearance setting which allows to define a clear space between the board edge and the copper pour. The board edge is defined as the center of the graphic lines on the edge.cuts layer. The problem is that the zone fill clearance setting doesn't use the center of the edge.cuts graphics lines, but the edge of those lines that is closest to it (madworm: I suspect the code doesn't care what object is in the way, be it a track or line). Undesired result - changing the width of those lines affects the zone pour. For screenshots and more see this link on KiCAD.info: https://forum.kicad.info/t/zone-setback-influenced-by-edgecut-line-thickness-why/1690
2016-01-01 19:17:28 jean-pierre charras kicad: status New Won't Fix
2017-08-03 14:10:50 Marcos Chaparro bug added subscriber Marcos Chaparro