Comment 30 for bug 510018

Revision history for this message
In , Christopher Parker (cparker15) wrote :

I think the WONTFIX resolution is pretty ridiculous. It's taking functionality away from a program and leaving an awfully broken mess behind.

I have a file server that I use to store all of my music that I access via SMB. I use KAudioCreator to rip CDs to a local directory ($HOME/Music) and then I move the music to the SMB share (ripping would take too long if I attempted to rip directly to the share).

I recently ripped a CD with KAudioCreator from a Finnish band that has letters with accents on them. I could access the files without a problem in the local directory. I then moved the files to the SMB share, and had issues with moving the files with accented characters in them (although the files appeared to have been successfully moved, as they no longer appeared in the local source directory).

Now, when I load the directory on the share that has these files in it, I'm immediately told the files don't exist, even though they clearly do, as they're showing up in the directory, although they show up as being 0B. I cannot rename them (although for some reason I'm unable to rename anything on the share). I cannot delete them. I cannot copy or move them back.

My question to you, Thiago, then, is: This is expected, normal behavior? I've somehow supposedly had five years to change my file-naming ways, even though another KDE application named the files to begin with? I think you need to re-evaluate how you're looking at this show-stopping bug. I now have no way of accessing these files, or other files that were pre-existing on the SMB shared drive that were perfectly accessible before the upgrade to KDE4. I experience this same issue when trying to access music from Björk, Green Jellÿ, Queensrÿche, Rinôçérôse, and more, which were all ripped under KDE3. If you're going to disable my access to my perfectly good files, you should at least be failing a lot more gracefully than this and providing an option for recovery while assuming I am an end user who doesn't know what a command line is.