Comment 139 for bug 510018

Revision history for this message
In , Hpj-u (hpj-u) wrote :

Calling this filesystem corruption is just an arrogant way to say:
we will not fix real world issues, we insist in the world fixing this.

Given, how easy it is to create such an item, e.g.:

 touch $(printf "snaf\374.txt")

this attitude is ridiculous.

Apart from unzip, we are bitten by a winscp/sshd combination, that doesn't encode properly
(all current versions).

@Thiago: wrongly encoded file names will *never* go away.

What would you thing, if the kernel would forbit access to files, that you saved in a crypted filesystem container, because its filename has an invalid encoding. Say, this contains an important work of yours. Guess what, you would call this kernel names.

Next logical step would be to automatically *format* such a media in order to prevent further propagation. Your argumentation would even justify this. But face it: middle age is over, and the world isn't turning around KDE, KDE is actively loosing users, because of this attitude.