Comment 87 for bug 45843

Revision history for this message
In , ultr (ultr) wrote :

Dotan Cohen:

Yes, inconsistent was what I meant.

> Therefore the fact that GTK apps will still
> have the problematic popup is not a reason
> to not fix this issue in Qt apps.

Not at all. I'm totally for this improvement in Qt.

I'm just saying it will not fix the problem everywhere, unless this change is implemented in every toolkit.
Or the fix is done somewhere else where it will affect all the applications, ex. in x11lib. But I guess they will not agree to modify grabbing system just because toolkits handle it wrong.

Susanne Oberhauser:

Are you sure you have tested it with popups like *context menus* or *main menus*?
Popup windows (ex. JavaScript alert() in web browsers) are not popups in this context, because they do not grab mouse and/or keyboard.