BACKGROUND
Exception unwinding requires some datastructures; specifically
the libgcc module unwind-dw2-fde.c has two-three statics.
These statics are protected by a gthread_mutex.
BUG
Arm build of libgcc builds gthread_mutex as no-op.
Thus applications cannot provide for example an RTOS
mutex with priority inheritance to protect above statics.
If I understand correctly, ARM toolchain build includes:
gthr-single.h
which dummies out the gthread functions as inline no-ops;
consequently they cannot be overridden.
SUGGESTIONS
A couple different approaches to fix this:
1) Create+use a separate gthreads module, including weak
no-op functions for the gthreads functions. Thus RTOS users
can provide an alternate implementation of gthreads
appropriate for their RTOS, and non-RTOS users are
unaffected.
2) Use thread-local storage instead of statics in unwind-dw2-fde.c?
Is there a architecture-independent TLS wrapper in gcc libcc?
Please let me know if you agree, and if I can help...
Thanks!
Best Regards, Dave
Concurrently throwing exceptions in multiple threads crashes.
This bug has impacted multiple commercial projects, some examples: /forums. xilinx. com/t5/ Embedded- Development- Tools/Re- building- the-SDK- libc-newlib- and-libgcc- for-reentrancy/ m-p/1164973 /www.arangodb. com/2019/ 09/when- exceptions- collide/ /forums. freertos. org/t/freertos- and-c-exception s/10911
https:/
https:/
https:/
BACKGROUND
Exception unwinding requires some datastructures; specifically
the libgcc module unwind-dw2-fde.c has two-three statics.
These statics are protected by a gthread_mutex.
BUG
Arm build of libgcc builds gthread_mutex as no-op.
Thus applications cannot provide for example an RTOS
mutex with priority inheritance to protect above statics.
If I understand correctly, ARM toolchain build includes:
gthr-single.h
which dummies out the gthread functions as inline no-ops;
consequently they cannot be overridden.
SUGGESTIONS
A couple different approaches to fix this:
1) Create+use a separate gthreads module, including weak
no-op functions for the gthreads functions. Thus RTOS users
can provide an alternate implementation of gthreads
appropriate for their RTOS, and non-RTOS users are
unaffected.
2) Use thread-local storage instead of statics in unwind-dw2-fde.c? independent TLS wrapper in gcc libcc?
Is there a architecture-
Please let me know if you agree, and if I can help...
Thanks!
Best Regards, Dave