Comment 3 for bug 278350

Revision history for this message
Mika Pflüger (mikapflueger) wrote : Re: [intrepid-beta] PCMCIA network-card working in hardy does not work

Hi,

I don't think the bug is a duplicate of bug #256054, because:
1. I tried the workaround described at bug #256054, that means I disabled the NetworkManager completely. It isn't loaded anymore (does not appear in boot log, or whatever the name of the output ist, that you get when you give nosplash at boot prompt) and 'ps aux | grep net' does not show any running instances (of course after a reboot after disabling the NetworkManager). Although NetworkManager can't do anything anymore, the dmesg-output is the same (not exactly, NetworkManager does not appear in dmesg, but it didn't appear around the PCMCIA-probes before, anyway, as I point out later), eth0 does not appear in ifconfig-output, and lspcmcia-vv gives exactly the same output. Or in short: It didn't change anything.

2. The problem arises far earlier than NetworkManager is being loaded. The problem arises during the stage in booting process when the hardware drivers are being loaded. That is before any runlevel. After that, when entering runlevel 2, roughly, ifup is excuted (without any special impact, as /dev/eth0 does not exist) and way after that (when entering runlevel 5), NetworkManager is executed and /could/ indeed interfere with any settings, if there would even be a network device. But there is none, and there are no special settings, it would just work fine with DHCP, if NM would set any device to that, but there is no networking device (virtually, physically it is sitting there blinking). Furthermore, before removing NetworkManager I could access NetworkManager and it was reporting "No ethernet device" or something like this. That means I can confirm that NetworkManager did not find any devices and can therefore not mess the configuration of these.

So I would say this is not a duplicate of bug #256054.