Comment 9 for bug 1372149

Revision history for this message
Susan Spencer (susan-spencer) wrote : Re: [Bug 1372149] [NEW] bzr-git does not preserve or ignore unknown extra fields

Hi Jelmer,

Since no one is supporting bzr tools anymore,
that leaves projects like mine (Valentina)
permanently broken in Launchpad.

The hg-git "issue" is that hg-git is now pulling *all* fields from hg
into git, which isn't a bug, this is considered to be an improvement.

According to the hg-git team, Dulwich either ignores
or preserves additional fields that it doesn't recognize.
The expectation is that bzr-git, which uses Dulwich,
should also either ignore or preserve these fields, but
instead bzr-git just crashes.

It's too bad that Canonical has stopped supporting bzr tools.
I heard a rumour that there was discussion about adding
support for git on Launchpad to remove dependence on
the dead bzr tools, but that this effort was not well received.
What a shame.