Issues using Qt Creator plugin versus "click build"

[Aaron Hastings]

When packaging my Ubuntu Touch app using the Qt Creator plugin, I am having numerous issues, including the "Comment" field in the .desktop file being removed altogether. These issues do not appear when running "click build" at the command line.

I have created two click packages - one using Qt Creator and the other using "click build" - then tested them using the "click-reviewers-tools" package:
https://launchpad.net/click-reviewers-tools

In the diff below, the file on the "left" is the output from click-run-checks on the Qt Creator-made package. The file on the "right" is the output of click-run-checks for the "click build"-made package.

7c7
< Installed-Size: 70
---
> Installed-Size: 105
20c20
< "installed-size": "70",
---
> "installed-size": "105",
27a28,29
> d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e .excludes
> 36eb095ea1d6cfa6464c448d7eeb1ed5 Makefile
35c37,42
< 1bb73e905fcdc755db29d7ac78219a06 uLuas.desktop
---
> 1df8cbcb6068c9a964a6c7ea643b4036 tests/autopilot/run
> b972993bfc648d1f105a9d7319cd2937 tests/autopilot/uLuas/__init__.py
> ff7eb67a14d5169bc5dc43177e8b18a3 tests/autopilot/uLuas/main/__init__.py
> 2ca27dabf56820db62b360590311d2cd tests/autopilot/uLuas/main/test_main.py
> 20481833f6658a972b8585a220f3c994 tests/unit/tst_hellocomponent.qml
> 00979ce41cd2600edefd16096d528153 uLuas.desktop
37a45,46
> 22560784282a385faaae3740cb431841 uLuas.qmlproject
> 2064f291982ace4395715333d6ae37b3 uLuas.qmlproject.user
60,61c69,70
< Comment=
< Exec=qmlscene $@ uLuas.qml
---
> Comment=Luas Dublin light rail app for Ubuntu Touch.
> Exec=/usr/bin/qmlscene $@ /usr/share/uLuas/uLuas.qml
130c139
< "desktop_validates (uLuas)": "did not validate: (ValidationError in file '/tmp/clickreview-q3xcia/uLuas.desktop': \n- Value of Key 'Comment' is empty )"
---
> "desktop_Exec (uLuas)": "absolute path '/usr/bin/qmlscene $@ /usr/share/uLuas/uLuas.qml' for Exec given in .desktop file."
134d142
< "desktop_Exec (uLuas)": "OK",
149c157,158
< "desktop_required_keys (uLuas)": "OK"
---
> "desktop_required_keys (uLuas)": "OK",
> "desktop_validates (uLuas)": "OK"
184c193
< org.thecosmicfrog.uluas_0.13_all.click: FAIL
---
> ../org.thecosmicfrog.uluas_0.13_all.click: FAIL

[Aaron Hastings (thecosmicfrog)]

Attaching output of click-run-checks for Qt Creator-built click package.

[Aaron Hastings (thecosmicfrog)]

Attaching output of click-run-checks for "click build"-built click package.

[Launchpad Janitor (janitor)]

This bug was fixed in the package qtcreator-plugin-ubuntu - 2.8.1.2-0ubuntu1

---------------
qtcreator-plugin-ubuntu (2.8.1.2-0ubuntu1) trusty; urgency=medium

  [Benjamin Zeller]
  * Enable Publish tab if the click-review tools are installed
  * Show detailed information about a error under the validation treeview
  * Install cmake to the click chroots
  * Packaging tab is renamed to Publish
  * Parser for click-run-checks output and show results in a itemview
  * Fix run on device for cmake projects
  * New cmake project template
  * cmake project deployment to the device
  * Automatically validate click packages created from CMake projects
  * Build click package for cmake projects
  * The menu.json parser is refactored to show menus only in a special context
  * New option to menu.json if a clicktarget is required for executing the action
  * Tweaking build files to allow local build.
  * Do not ship a comment in the desktop file, because manifest should take precedence
  * The manifest desciption always takes precedence over the desktop file (LP: #1264404)
  * Read script output with QString::fromLocal8Bit instead of fromLatin1 (LP: #1211169)
  * Added cmake build and maintenance support for click chroots

  [Alexandre Abreu]
  * HTML5 app deployment on device is fixed
  * Fixed HTML5 template to have a cleaner example of tabs implementation
  * Updated HTML5 tab structure

  [David Barth]
  * Tool to download a pre-compiled cordova runtime (LP: #1277667)

  [Zoltan Balogh]
  * Emulator features rebased on ubuntu-emulator
  * Remove forced update of the maintainer in the manifest.json (LP: #1274265)
  * Removed gksu from the dependency list (LP: #1235531)
  * The click package reviewing tool is executed on the click package created in the Packaging tab.
  * Enable scope templates on Trusty (LP: #1263593)
 -- Zoltan Balogh <email address hidden> Thu, 13 Feb 2014 11:50:52 +0200