Activity log for bug #952636

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2012-03-12 00:15:10 JaSauders bug added bug
2012-03-12 00:18:09 Ubuntu Foundations Team Bug Bot tags bot-comment
2012-03-13 16:17:50 Fabio Marconi affects ubuntu gnome-control-center (Ubuntu)
2012-03-13 16:18:02 Fabio Marconi gnome-control-center (Ubuntu): status New Confirmed
2012-03-13 16:23:41 Fabio Marconi description While I was rather frustrated with the fact there was no ACL-based feature within Ubuntu/Linux to allow certain users to have certain access to folders, I worked around it with the group feature. In a perfect world, I would be able to say "Bob, Jim, Frank, read+write access to /media/public", but I cannot do that because there is no ACL based feature. (Hate to say it, but see OSX "get info" for an idea). To work around it, I've just created a new group and added Bob, Jim, and Frank to that group, then added that group to /media/public or whichever folder I'm targeting. It seems as if that functionality has been removed in 12.04.... really? Why would we remove needed features such as this from the GUI that was just fine the way it was? In closing - I'd really like to see that group management feature back. Several users I've spoken to just within the last 15 minutes alone have shared similar frustration. It was so easy to use... But in a perfect world, the ACL idea would be nothing short of amazing to see... Thank you for your time! **Workaround** Install gnome-system-tools to have again users and groups as before While I was rather frustrated with the fact there was no ACL-based feature within Ubuntu/Linux to allow certain users to have certain access to folders, I worked around it with the group feature. In a perfect world, I would be able to say "Bob, Jim, Frank, read+write access to /media/public", but I cannot do that because there is no ACL based feature. (Hate to say it, but see OSX "get info" for an idea). To work around it, I've just created a new group and added Bob, Jim, and Frank to that group, then added that group to /media/public or whichever folder I'm targeting. It seems as if that functionality has been removed in 12.04.... really? Why would we remove needed features such as this from the GUI that was just fine the way it was? In closing - I'd really like to see that group management feature back. Several users I've spoken to just within the last 15 minutes alone have shared similar frustration. It was so easy to use... But in a perfect world, the ACL idea would be nothing short of amazing to see... Thank you for your time!
2012-03-13 16:24:15 Fabio Marconi tags bot-comment bot-comment oneiric precise workaround
2012-03-13 17:49:12 Sebastien Bacher gnome-control-center (Ubuntu): importance Undecided Wishlist
2012-03-13 17:49:14 Sebastien Bacher gnome-control-center (Ubuntu): status Confirmed Triaged
2012-05-23 08:07:58 Mantas Kriaučiūnas bug task added baltix
2012-09-22 14:21:03 Jeremy Bícha gnome-control-center (Ubuntu): status Triaged Invalid