Comment 59 for bug 733349

Revision history for this message
Cas (calumlind) wrote : Re: Minimize windows upon clicking application's launcher

Marco Biscaro on Ayatana Mailing List (https://lists.launchpad.net/ayatana/msg05553.html)
> It's very simple: there is one dash to one launcher icon. The same for
indicators: one menu for each indicator.
> Again, the problem with launcher icons is: each application can have
zero or more windows.
> On GNOME desktop and on Windows, a click on the panel/taskbar minimize
the window because each window has an "button" on panel/taskbar.
> Instead of just criticize the current design, why don't you write a
specification and mockups to propose changes? They can be discussed
here, on the mailing list, and implemented for Oneiric (it's too late to
changes for Natty).
>All kind of improvements are welcome, but we need something concrete and
well defined. :-)

The only reason you not implementing this is because of multiple windows?! Clearly you never used Docky as they managed it just fine by minimizing ALL windows. Just to add, Windows XP had window grouping and then a 'minimize group' on right click.

You do not need a mockup as everyone who has commented on this bug has expressed identically use case scenarios that make perfect sense. That's 50 or so replies reiterating the OP's proposal, I think that is pretty concrete and defined to me.

I have yet to read a single comment that makes a valid argument against implementing this proposal. The resistance by the developers is rather odd considering that Unity is meant to improve the user experience.