Comment 1 for bug 1533349

Revision history for this message
Martin Pitt (pitti) wrote : Re: StacktraceAddressSignature is generated using suboptimal function

What is the exact issue here?

> the function crash_signature_addresses is used to create the StacktraceAddressSignature.

Yes, but that's not a bug, but by design. This is being used for client-side (whoopsie) duplicate detection, and we can't rely on a "real" crash signature on the client side. The retracer on the other hand should stop looking at SAS once it figured out a crash_signature(). We should not muddy the semantics of SAS by sometimes putting in different information.

Can you please explain what the real issue is here? I figure we need to change something in apport-retrace or crashdb.py, but I don't think this should change the behaviour of user boxes that report crashes.

Thanks!