Activity log for bug #508137

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2010-01-15 22:10:03 sven bug added bug
2010-01-15 22:11:01 sven description Upstart needs some clear way to define whether jobs should start early or late, and before or after another job in the boot process. To put it short it needs a priority value for jobs like the old ordering of startup scripts by name. For a fast startup on desktop systems I want all desktop related jobs to start before server jobs. Currently, there seems to be no easy way to achieve this. Jobs with little event dependencies for startup simply come first which is ok for server systems, but not for desktop systems. E.g. mythtv-backend comes with a startup script that only depends on local-filesystems so it gets started very early which is not desirable for desktop systems. It should startup only after gdm (and user session) have finished loading. i.e. all jobs need a priority field to put them early or late in the boot while respecting event dependencies. And second: when do upstart jobs get started in respect to legacy init.d scripts which have not been converted, yet? I wonder how I can force mysql server, for example, to start up later in the boot process. Regards Sven Upstart needs some clear way to define whether jobs should start early or late, and before or after another job in the boot process. To put it short it needs a priority value for jobs like the old ordering of startup scripts by name. For a fast startup on desktop systems I want all desktop related jobs to start before server jobs. Currently, there seems to be no easy way to achieve this. Jobs with little event dependencies for startup simply come first which is ok for server systems, but not for desktop systems. E.g. mythtv-backend comes with a startup script that only depends on local-filesystems so it gets started very early which is not desirable for desktop systems. It should startup only after gdm (and user session) have finished loading. i.e. all jobs need a priority field to put them early or late in the boot while respecting event dependencies. And second: when do upstart jobs get started in respect to legacy init.d scripts which have not been converted, yet? I wonder how I can force mysql server, for example, to start up later in the boot process. Regards Sven
2010-01-18 21:00:50 Scott James Remnant (Canonical) upstart: status New Triaged
2010-01-18 21:00:52 Scott James Remnant (Canonical) upstart: importance Undecided Wishlist
2010-01-18 21:01:18 Scott James Remnant (Canonical) summary upstart needs a way to define startup priorities init: needs a way to define startup priorities