Unknown albums and unknown artists should not be shown
Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ubuntu Music App |
New
|
Undecided
|
Unassigned | ||
thumbnailer (Ubuntu) |
Triaged
|
Undecided
|
Unassigned |
Bug Description
Unpack the attached archive into the Music folder and wait for mediascanner to finish indexing (takes a few minutes).
Now look at the album tab in the music app. There are hundreds of unknown albums at the beginning of the list.
The attached music collection has a lot of poorly tagged songs in it (just like many users' collections will have imperfectly tagged songs). There are lots of songs with an empty album tag. (Such songs are legit too because I might add, say, audio recordings of a meeting or audio books to my collection.)
The music app shows a separate "Unknown Album" for each and every song with an empty album tag. That's wrong. It should not show any album at all in this case because, by definition, a song with no album tag isn't part of any album--it's a stand-along song.
(Note that collapsing all songs without an album tag into a single album not an option because it would conflate many unrelated tracks into a single album that doesn't exist.)
This is how the mediascanner scope deals with empty albums; the music app should do the same thing.
summary: |
- Unknown albums should not be shown + Unknown albums and unknown artists should not be shown |
We've discussed this before, and instead of showing a blank album or artist we decided to show "Unknown Album" or "Unknown Artist". Note that we did decide to filter out any blank genre from the Genres view. I agree with you--I think it'd be preferable to just filter any blank/null Album/Artist. Songs that are missing this data will show up in the Songs view.
ahayzen or popey, do you agree?