Activity log for bug #1815374

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2019-02-10 18:39:47 Jeremy Bícha bug added bug
2019-02-24 20:10:59 Jeremy Bícha description The Ubuntu Desktop Team would like to get policykit-1-gnome demoted to universe since it is no longer used in the default install. (See its package description.) I believe screen-resolution-extra is the last thing holding that package in main. gnome-shell provides polkit-1-auth-agent. You can see provides and reverse depends for a virtual package by running $ apt-cache showpkg polkit-1-auth-agent In my experience with demoting xterm to universe, it looked to me like Ubuntu's germinate doesn't handle virtual packages and alternate dependencies very well. I ended up having to put gnome-terminal as the first dependency in the list of alternates. Suggestion 1 ------------ Change screen-resolution-extra's dependency to: gnome-shell | policykit-1-gnome | polkit-1-auth-agent Suggestion 2 ------------ Change nvidia-settings to Suggest instead of Depend on screen-resolution-extra. From the package's description, it sounds like screen-resolution-extra is not useful for a default Ubuntu install? If so, we can demote both screen-resolution-extra and policykit-1-gnome to universe. The Ubuntu Desktop Team would like to get policykit-1-gnome demoted to universe since it is no longer used in the default install. (See its package description.) I believe screen-resolution-extra is the last thing holding that package in main. gnome-shell provides polkit-1-auth-agent. You can see provides and reverse depends for a virtual package by running $ apt-cache showpkg polkit-1-auth-agent In my experience with demoting xterm to universe, it looked to me like Ubuntu's germinate doesn't handle virtual packages and alternate dependencies very well. I ended up having to put gnome-terminal as the first dependency in the list of alternates. Suggestion 1 ------------ Change screen-resolution-extra's dependency to: gnome-shell <!s390x> | policykit-1-gnome <!s390x> | polkit-1-auth-agent <!s390x> The !s390x is because gnome-shell isn't available on s390x currently and there isn't an alternative auth agent available in main. Suggestion 2 ------------ Change nvidia-settings to Suggest instead of Depend on screen-resolution-extra. From the package's description, it sounds like screen-resolution-extra is not useful for a default Ubuntu install? If so, we can demote both screen-resolution-extra and policykit-1-gnome to universe.
2019-02-24 20:13:54 Jeremy Bícha description The Ubuntu Desktop Team would like to get policykit-1-gnome demoted to universe since it is no longer used in the default install. (See its package description.) I believe screen-resolution-extra is the last thing holding that package in main. gnome-shell provides polkit-1-auth-agent. You can see provides and reverse depends for a virtual package by running $ apt-cache showpkg polkit-1-auth-agent In my experience with demoting xterm to universe, it looked to me like Ubuntu's germinate doesn't handle virtual packages and alternate dependencies very well. I ended up having to put gnome-terminal as the first dependency in the list of alternates. Suggestion 1 ------------ Change screen-resolution-extra's dependency to: gnome-shell <!s390x> | policykit-1-gnome <!s390x> | polkit-1-auth-agent <!s390x> The !s390x is because gnome-shell isn't available on s390x currently and there isn't an alternative auth agent available in main. Suggestion 2 ------------ Change nvidia-settings to Suggest instead of Depend on screen-resolution-extra. From the package's description, it sounds like screen-resolution-extra is not useful for a default Ubuntu install? If so, we can demote both screen-resolution-extra and policykit-1-gnome to universe. The Ubuntu Desktop Team would like to get policykit-1-gnome demoted to universe since it is no longer used in the default install. (See its package description.) I believe screen-resolution-extra is the last thing holding that package in main. gnome-shell provides polkit-1-auth-agent. You can see provides and reverse depends for a virtual package by running $ apt-cache showpkg polkit-1-auth-agent In my experience with demoting xterm to universe, it looked to me like Ubuntu's germinate doesn't handle virtual packages and alternate dependencies very well. I ended up having to put gnome-terminal as the first dependency in the list of alternates. Suggestion 1 ------------ Change screen-resolution-extra's dependency to: gnome-shell | policykit-1-gnome | polkit-1-auth-agent Suggestion 2 ------------ Change nvidia-settings to Suggest instead of Depend on screen-resolution-extra. From the package's description, it sounds like screen-resolution-extra is not useful for a default Ubuntu install? If so, we can demote both screen-resolution-extra and policykit-1-gnome to universe.
2019-02-25 16:28:28 Alberto Milone screen-resolution-extra (Ubuntu): status New Triaged
2019-02-25 16:28:31 Alberto Milone screen-resolution-extra (Ubuntu): importance Undecided Medium
2019-02-25 16:28:33 Alberto Milone screen-resolution-extra (Ubuntu): assignee Alberto Milone (albertomilone)
2019-03-11 15:12:07 Alberto Milone screen-resolution-extra (Ubuntu): status Triaged In Progress
2019-03-13 13:36:26 Launchpad Janitor screen-resolution-extra (Ubuntu): status In Progress Fix Released