Activity log for bug #581886

Date Who What changed Old value New value Message
2010-05-17 19:02:31 Ganton bug added bug
2010-05-17 19:05:28 Ganton description In some systems, you have to put a package "on hold" to avoid it is updated. Then, if you execute sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get dist-upgrade it tells you that those packages are "on hold" and are not going to be updated. Correct. But sooner or later appears the automatic graphical updating tool appears (I suppose it's Kpackagekit or "kubuntu-notification-helper") and tells you to update the package! And this keeps happening from time to time, it doesn't learn or work OK. WHAT IT IS EXPECTED TO HAPPEN That the automatic graphical updating tool worked like the CLI tool and knew when that a package "on hold" must not be updated. KUBUNTU VERSION: Kubuntu 10.04 MORE INFORMATION: To put a package to hold: echo "package_name hold" | sudo dpkg --set-selections to 'unhold' it: echo "package_name install" | sudo dpkg --set-selecions To see which are your packages 'on hold': dpkg --get-selections | grep hold In some systems, you have to put "on hold" a package X to avoid it is updated. Then, if you execute     sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get dist-upgrade it tells you that the package X is "on hold" and that is not going to be updated. Correct. But sooner or later appears the automatic graphical updating tool appears (I suppose it's Kpackagekit or "kubuntu-notification-helper") and tells you to update the package X! And this keeps happening from time to time, it doesn't learn or work OK. WHAT IT IS EXPECTED TO HAPPEN That the automatic graphical updating tool worked like the CLI tool and knew that when a package is "on hold"... must not be updated. KUBUNTU VERSION: Kubuntu 10.04 MORE INFORMATION:     To put a package to hold:     echo "package_name hold" | sudo dpkg --set-selections     to 'unhold' it:     echo "package_name install" | sudo dpkg --set-selecions     To see which are your packages 'on hold':     dpkg --get-selections | grep hold
2010-05-17 19:05:54 Ganton description In some systems, you have to put "on hold" a package X to avoid it is updated. Then, if you execute     sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get dist-upgrade it tells you that the package X is "on hold" and that is not going to be updated. Correct. But sooner or later appears the automatic graphical updating tool appears (I suppose it's Kpackagekit or "kubuntu-notification-helper") and tells you to update the package X! And this keeps happening from time to time, it doesn't learn or work OK. WHAT IT IS EXPECTED TO HAPPEN That the automatic graphical updating tool worked like the CLI tool and knew that when a package is "on hold"... must not be updated. KUBUNTU VERSION: Kubuntu 10.04 MORE INFORMATION:     To put a package to hold:     echo "package_name hold" | sudo dpkg --set-selections     to 'unhold' it:     echo "package_name install" | sudo dpkg --set-selecions     To see which are your packages 'on hold':     dpkg --get-selections | grep hold In some systems, you have to put "on hold" a package X to avoid it is updated. Then, if you execute     sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get dist-upgrade it tells you that the package X is "on hold" and that is not going to be updated. Correct. But sooner or later appears the automatic graphical updating tool (I suppose it's Kpackagekit or "kubuntu-notification-helper") and tells you to update the package X! And this keeps happening from time to time, it doesn't learn or work OK. WHAT IT IS EXPECTED TO HAPPEN That the automatic graphical updating tool worked like the CLI tool and knew that when a package is "on hold"... must not be updated. KUBUNTU VERSION: Kubuntu 10.04 MORE INFORMATION:     To put a package to hold:     echo "package_name hold" | sudo dpkg --set-selections     to 'unhold' it:     echo "package_name install" | sudo dpkg --set-selecions     To see which are your packages 'on hold':     dpkg --get-selections | grep hold
2010-05-23 22:33:36 Waleed Hamra affects ubuntu kpackagekit (Ubuntu)
2010-05-23 22:40:53 Waleed Hamra kpackagekit (Ubuntu): status New Confirmed
2010-06-05 00:02:15 Jonathan Thomas affects kpackagekit (Ubuntu) packagekit (Ubuntu)
2010-06-05 00:02:15 Jonathan Thomas packagekit (Ubuntu): importance Undecided Low
2010-06-05 00:02:15 Jonathan Thomas packagekit (Ubuntu): status Confirmed Triaged
2010-06-05 00:02:40 Jonathan Thomas summary Kubuntu updates do not respect "hold" state of packages. PackageKit does not respect "hold" state of packages.
2011-06-03 00:55:22 Matthias Klumpp packagekit (Ubuntu): status Triaged Fix Released