Memtest86+ finds errors in almost every computer

Bug #1090116 reported by dr.spock
6
This bug affects 1 person
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
memtest86+ (Ubuntu)
New
Undecided
Unassigned

Bug Description

In last Ubuntu releases (at least Kubuntu 64 bit ones), if you run Memtest86+ from GRUB, you'll get infinite errors on test #7. It makes Memtest86+ unreliable, so unuseful.

Now I'm using Kubuntu 12.10 64 bit, but in my shop's lab we have found this bug on several flavors and versions.

dr.spock (dr.spock)
affects: linux (Ubuntu) → memtest86+ (Ubuntu)
Revision history for this message
Tom van Leeuwen (mrzx4l98d4tp89jab6giohdrjqysbyjs4npz2ccq25kvjmf5h8u4cmidcko7s4tfr6ur1teuv4ju1af4klpdqp0vd87ddz5sh53mwfrw5819ohmadctcbsrykdp4exz2w0xzyv54zb4ksnirbzfvybudw577zswcymukpheqeiptvlrx87cyumfa232omr5gcyxpni3rwgnjdqw38fhshrdw19z5s2fyst45o0e5sk2nk-ubuntu) wrote :

I have a Compaq N610c (Pentium 4 1.8ghz, relatively old) and also experience problems with test 7.
However, I don't see the problem with the original build from www.memtest.org.
More details will follow soon.

Revision history for this message
Tom van Leeuwen (mrzx4l98d4tp89jab6giohdrjqysbyjs4npz2ccq25kvjmf5h8u4cmidcko7s4tfr6ur1teuv4ju1af4klpdqp0vd87ddz5sh53mwfrw5819ohmadctcbsrykdp4exz2w0xzyv54zb4ksnirbzfvybudw577zswcymukpheqeiptvlrx87cyumfa232omr5gcyxpni3rwgnjdqw38fhshrdw19z5s2fyst45o0e5sk2nk-ubuntu) wrote :

Bad words are 0x00000000 if test 7 is started immediately, else they correspond to the last written pattern before i ran test #7.

Since i only see the problem with i386 builds (my machine is i386 but the x64 version of memtest seems to run fine), i decided to re-build the memtest from the source package. However, this did not make any difference.

memtest86+_4.20-1.1ubuntu2_i386: False errors on test #7 (both self-build and original)
memtest86+_4.20-1.1ubuntu2_x64: No false errors

I forgot to mention that the PC is a laptop. I have an identical one but haven't been able to run memtest on that laptop yet. I tested with a 256MB and (later) with only a 1GB memory module.

Revision history for this message
Tom van Leeuwen (mrzx4l98d4tp89jab6giohdrjqysbyjs4npz2ccq25kvjmf5h8u4cmidcko7s4tfr6ur1teuv4ju1af4klpdqp0vd87ddz5sh53mwfrw5819ohmadctcbsrykdp4exz2w0xzyv54zb4ksnirbzfvybudw577zswcymukpheqeiptvlrx87cyumfa232omr5gcyxpni3rwgnjdqw38fhshrdw19z5s2fyst45o0e5sk2nk-ubuntu) wrote :

Oops, this bug was already reported and fixed: Bug #1071209

To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.