Comment 40 for bug 463940

Revision history for this message
irwjager (jager49) wrote :

It honestly seems like this BIOS was commissioned by a baboon. It should've never passed QA like this. I'm taking my Envy back for a refund. There is only so much time I can spend on debugging something that should just work.

To recap our findings so far;

    * Fans not working (at least on F.04).
    * Thermal zone/sensors not working.
    * ACPI parsing aborts in several places due to initialization bugs (Linux does work around this)
    * CPU Powersaving (aka C-State switching) only works if you boot the machine without AC adapter attached.
    * No critical shutdown temperature returned for anything else but Windows.

In short, this BIOS is a recipe for a cooked CPU: all cores are always awake, all of the time (generating copious amounts of heat). Heat which is insufficiently dissipated by the fans (they don't seem to throttle at any temperature). The OS can't shut down the machine if it gets too hot because it is kept in the dark about 1. the current temperature 2. what temperature is considered critical.

Nice.