Comment 18 for bug 502426

Revision history for this message
Surak (smkozasa) wrote : Re: [Bug 502426] Re: DVD playback broken in Karmic

I suppose it is the logical conclusion, since changing the DVD drive
region code allowed me to watch most DVDs I own (region 4). As far as I
know, libdvdcss SHOULD be able to do a workaround through this region
restrictions, but since it wasn't working with original region code
(region 1) and when I changed it to the same region as my discs (region
4) it started to work, we can get to the conclusion that libdvdcss is
doing its job partially, only, being able to decode protected DVDs, but
ONLY if the drive's region code is the same as the disc's.

And I can see why most people didn't notice this bug before: most people
DO have DVD drives with the same region code as the discs they own.

Surak

---

Em 09-10-2010 16:49, Will escreveu:
> Surak if you're saying you think think this is a libdvdcss bug. From
> what I can see here, I would probably agree, as every log posted
> includes the 'Media region code is mismatched to logical unit region'
> line, so libdvdcss clearly isn't doing its job correctly. If so perhaps
> we should mark it as affecting that package to get the attention of the
> maintainers.
>
>